I know you're all really trying to be helpful, but telling me I haven't had the experience and don't know how to use the camera isn't helping. I know I have to re-learn a lot of stuff, but I've tested the camera, and it doesnt work for me; the retailer has tested the camera, and it doesn't work for them. I know I'm stupid, but if it doesn't work for them either, does it not figure that there's a fault?
KWJ, I took the Hoya CIR-PL off to see if it made any difference - none whatsoever, if anything the pictures are even more out of focus, especially in low light.
Marcel, I wasn't using a tripod. The unsharp one was taken at 1/125 f5.6 @105 mm on Program mode. The sharp photo was taken at 1/250 f5.6 @ 92mm on Program mode. I imagine the slightly higher shutter speed was a combination of the fact that the sun was shining in the sharp photo, plus a slightly lower focal length (which was purely unintentional, I must have adjusted it by mistake). Since nothing in the photo is in focus I can only deduce that AF has focused beyond infinity, which as I now understand, is a safety feature built into lenses to protect the AF motor. If the foreground was in focus, I would understand that it was picking up something in the foreground that I didnt notice, but that isn't the case.
And the other wee thing. If it was only happening in one or two images, I'd understand it was maybe operator error, but to have 2 sharp images out of 140 is not a good average. I might be wrong some of the time, heck I might be wrong most of the time, but I'm not wrong all of the time, and especially not when I set the camera to SCENE LANDSCAPE, where I'd expect it to get things perfectly right (and it's still not focusing properly.)