XQD or CFexpress type B

Peter7100

Senior Member
Any experience or thoughts on these cards. Both seem to be in a similar price range, so what one would you go for and why?
 

Clovishound

Senior Member
I assume you mean XQD or CFexpress. My understanding is that CFexpress type B is a newer, faster technology. I rarely see the XQD cards offered for sale anymore, which suggests they are being left behind. On B&H, I see 173 CFexpress cards, but only 2 XQD. The 2 XQD cards are 440 Read and 400 Write running around $140 for 64MB. The Sandisk 64MB CFexpress cards are 1500 Read and 800 Write, and are $110 on sale, with a regular price of $150. To me the CFexpress is the clear winner.

I use CFexpress in my 7ii and 8, and would recommend going with the newer technology.
 

nikonbill

Senior Member
Contributor
I use the CFexpress type B in both the D500 and the D850 - Clovishound explains very well above the why

Here in the US XQD were hard to find (when I was shopping)
 

Clovishound

Senior Member
I ran across this page. It's over a year old, but it gives some real world results on card speeds. It turns out a lot of cards are rated at far higher speeds than this individual's test results. The XQD cards tested were closer to advertised speeds, but still well below most of the CFexpress cards.

Fastest memory cards for Nikon
 

nikonbill

Senior Member
Contributor
so what one would you go for and why?
One thing I remembered noting in reviews was "heating up" during operation - also look for reviews using your camera and a style similar to your desires (such as video/long burst) as it looks to make a difference in reviews I've read
 

Clovishound

Senior Member
Even with a fast card, I can over run the buffer on my Z8 at 20 fps and RAW. Your 6ii should have less trouble with that since the files are half the size, and max fps is 14. I couldn't easily find the max speed the 6ii will download to the card, as that can sometimes be the bottleneck.
 

bluzman

Senior Member
I bought an XQD for my D500 back in the day. It was quite a step up from an SD card back then. The D500 is gone so the XQD is now the backup to the CFExpress Type B in my Z6iii. CFExpress is faster but both cards have been reliable.
 

benhasajeep

New member
XQD basically failed in the market due to a couple reasons. Limited use, limited number of manufacturers. CF Express B came along soon after being faster and more reliable.
 

Peter7100

Senior Member
Thanks for all the replies. I have just added a z7 to my kit, hence the reason I need to purchase one of the above cards. Sounds like the CF express type B is the one to go for :D
 

Patrick M

Senior Member
For the last 15 months I’ve been using a Sabrent 1Tb SSD in a Zitay CFX adapter exactly as per Jo Nuzzo’s Video.
It continues to work really well in my Z8

alas since then the cost of SSD memory has doubled.
 
Last edited:

hark

Administrator
Staff member
Super Mod
Contributor
Peter, this just showed up for me this morning. Maybe it will help you decide (unless you already saw it). It's by Fstoppers.

 

Peter7100

Senior Member
Thanks everyone and I am now the owner of a CF express type B card. Picked up a Sandisk for £89, which is not too bad.
All working well however I notice after transferring files to PC via a card reader, the card feels warm. I have seen other people mentioning this online and seems strange why just after a few seconds of uploading a few files this should happen.
 

Clovishound

Senior Member
That is normal, Peter. These are fast cards and any reading or writing creates a fair amount of heat. If you shoot a good amount of photos and immediately remove the card, it will be quite warm.

I've had my camera shut down shooting with a "hot card" warning a few times. This was mostly when shooting a lot of pre release capture back to back. It has only happened a handful of times in the last 1 1/2 of use, and clears fairly quickly. You should have less trouble with that since your image files are half the size of mine.

There's a reason the back of the card is metal vs plastic on SD cards. I'm sure there is a heat sync that metal back snuggles up against inside the card slot.
 

hark

Administrator
Staff member
Super Mod
Contributor
That is normal, Peter. These are fast cards and any reading or writing creates a fair amount of heat. If you shoot a good amount of photos and immediately remove the card, it will be quite warm.

I've had my camera shut down shooting with a "hot card" warning a few times. This was mostly when shooting a lot of pre release capture back to back. It has only happened a handful of times in the last 1 1/2 of use, and clears fairly quickly. You should have less trouble with that since your image files are half the size of mine.

There's a reason the back of the card is metal vs plastic on SD cards. I'm sure there is a heat sync that metal back snuggles up against inside the card slot.
Good info. I wasn't aware of the heat generated when transferring the images. Thanks.
 

nikonbill

Senior Member
Contributor
I notice after transferring files to PC via a card reader, the card feels warm. I have seen other people mentioning this online and seems strange why just after a few seconds of uploading a few files this should happen.
Hi Peter, glad you found something reasonable, I have and use SanDisk as they have a good name and have always been reliable for me.

On the heat subject, there is a lot of circuits inside cards of all types. The the CFexpress having "more" going on inside to allow transfer rates creates the warmth you feel. Electronics doing "work" can generate heat, like our computers would fry in minutes without cooling fans. Electronic heat is and always has been work based, small circuits doing a lot get warm.

Like the very simple example of a too small size extension cord running too large of an appliance gets warm (or hot) as long as its "big enough" for safety it lives a good life.

There are likely more circuits inside a CFexpress card than an early personal computer, and their small size is creating the heat. If they were bigger they would get less hot, but they would not be as small as we want. They are built to "take" it and have shut down mechanics (as pointed out above) if we "over do it"
 

Clovishound

Senior Member
Thanks for the reply.
I was using the card with my newly acquired Z7, so I think we might have the same file sizes.
I was thinking you were using the 6iii. Still, the Z7 only runs at 10 fps RAW vs the 20 on my Z8. It also doesn't have pre release capture, which is where I have had almost all of my hot card situations. So, you likely won't have as much trouble with hot card.
 
Top