What is the best filter to leave on a lens? skylight, UV, or ND

Status
Not open for further replies.

Marcel

Happily retired
Staff member
Super Mod
I did not ask if a filter was needed, I ask which kind was best to leave on the lens. That said I checked my 80-200 filter today and it is scratched to hell from the thorns in the woods, so I need a new filter there too.
In a case like this, the best filter to leave on the lens for walking in the woods is:

Drum roll.....

The lens cap.
 

Horoscope Fish

Senior Member
In a case like this, the best filter to leave on the lens for walking in the woods is:

Drum roll.....

The lens cap.
Except you can't shoot through them like you can a filter. Not too mention lens caps can be tricky to remove quickly, especially when buried under a deep lens lens hood like the one my 70-200; and that even once I do have it removed I then need to stow the cap in some fashion to free up my other hand for shooting because those big f/2.8's have caps the size of salad plates. If I'm shooting landscapes this scenario is less of an issue. If I'm shooting wild life it very much IS a an issue for me.

No offense to anyone intended here, but here's a radical thought: Maybe the person best able to determine if I need a filter on my lens, just maaaaybe... That person is me? And what if we extend that logic to, say... Everyone?
....
 

Marcel

Happily retired
Staff member
Super Mod
Except you can't shoot through them like you can a filter. Not too mention lens caps can be tricky to remove quickly, especially when buried under a deep lens lens hood like the one my 70-200; and that even once I do have it removed I then need to stow the cap in some fashion to free up my other hand for shooting because those big f/2.8's have caps the size of salad plates. If I'm shooting landscapes this scenario is less of an issue. If I'm shooting wild life it very much IS a an issue for me.

No offense to anyone intended here, but here's a radical thought: Maybe the person best able to determine if I need a filter on my lens, just maaaaybe... That person is me? And what if we extend that logic to, say... Everyone?
....
But I did write "for walking". Once you get to where you want to shoot from, then you should remove the lens cap.
Now I did write my first post with tongue in cheek if you get my drift. The OP had seeded a few controversial posts across the forum.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top