I haven't followed that thread but it sounds like I'm in your camp. I've always believed that the glass used and the photographer's eye are MUCH more important than the camera body itself. Good glass produces a sharper image and better color than cheap glass. And there's no disputing the value of skills (i.e. composition, use of DOF, etc).
Period. End of story.
Heck, I've seen beautiful pictures taken with a 3.2MP Powershot.
Period. End of story.
Heck, I've seen beautiful pictures taken with a 3.2MP Powershot.