Robert, sorry pal but i'm afraid you did start sarcastically - " here we go again " for one.. " i think i'll write a disclaimer " etc
Those are sacrcastic.. You state ' this is not a portrait ' yet its here in the portrait section. You obviously expect some kind of response or you wouldnt have posted it at all. So, what response were you hoping for, from a forum made up of mostly amateurs ?
Someone expressed an opinion, which is surely why its here.
It looks like you have stated these things before somewhere .. "I've tried to explain the reason for the lighting.." and " I'm not sure that people understand what is meant by and what the intent is for a commercial head shot. It's not a portrait "
If people here aren't getting it, I dont see the point of posting it.