Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Eyelight" data-source="post: 337041" data-attributes="member: 24753">Looking at the concern of @<a href="http://nikonites.com/member-16749-bob-blaylock.html" target="_blank">Bob Blaylock</a>. I cannot necessarily speak for anyone else, including the Weekly&nbsp; Challenge Team.&nbsp; I frame it this way because the Weekly Challenge is&nbsp; pretty much wide open to the individual photographer's interpretation,&nbsp; imagination and even capabilities.&nbsp; Participants are free to explore any&nbsp; direction the challenge leads them and learn from the experience.It&nbsp; is a photo challenge, so kind of a given that the entries involve&nbsp; photography.&nbsp; And though maybe more PS than photo, the image in [USER=13196]@hark[/USER] 's&nbsp; post does involve photography.I suppose if an entry appeared to&nbsp; be entirely CG, then it may be considered outside the guidelines, but&nbsp; if within the posted guidelines &amp; rules, the final word on acceptability of a&nbsp; particular method will be decided by the likes an entry receives.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Eyelight, post: 337041, member: 24753"] Looking at the concern of @[URL="http://nikonites.com/member-16749-bob-blaylock.html"][B]Bob Blaylock[/B][/URL]. I cannot necessarily speak for anyone else, including the Weekly Challenge Team. I frame it this way because the Weekly Challenge is pretty much wide open to the individual photographer's interpretation, imagination and even capabilities. Participants are free to explore any direction the challenge leads them and learn from the experience. It is a photo challenge, so kind of a given that the entries involve photography. And though maybe more PS than photo, the image in [USER=13196]@hark[/USER] 's post does involve photography. I suppose if an entry appeared to be entirely CG, then it may be considered outside the guidelines, but if within the posted guidelines & rules, the final word on acceptability of a particular method will be decided by the likes an entry receives. [/QUOTE]

Verification