Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="BackdoorArts" data-source="post: 332329" data-attributes="member: 9240">I hear you.&nbsp; I wouldn't call it lazy, because Lightroom edits are just reorganized ACR edits, but if you've abandoned PS entirely then ... well ... truthfully only you know if you should have done work in PS or if the LR edits were enough.&nbsp; You can do an awful lot in LR, and really don't need PS for most editing.&nbsp; But this is the first ACR function I've found that I can't replicate in Lightroom.&nbsp; Hopefully someone will tell me differently.And I should add, when my brother shoots RAW he says that no matter what he does in ACR, cropped or otherwise, he just resized to 24MP's automatically before editing.&nbsp; With the image I used in the video I decided to take a shot and upsize a cropped D7000 image to D800 size (36MP), and the truth is I could have easily used it as a starting point for my editing.&nbsp; I would never consider doing that level of resizing for all my D600 and D7100 shots now, but I'm just glad that I haven't dived head first in to my Yosemite Park re-editing project, where I have a bunch of D7000 and D90 images that deserve a second edit with 3 more years' experience under my belt.&nbsp; I may actually be able to print that 16x20 landscape over the fireplace now.&nbsp; LOL</blockquote>

[QUOTE="BackdoorArts, post: 332329, member: 9240"] I hear you. I wouldn't call it lazy, because Lightroom edits are just reorganized ACR edits, but if you've abandoned PS entirely then ... well ... truthfully only you know if you [I]should [/I]have done work in PS or if the LR edits were enough. You can do an awful lot in LR, and really don't need PS for most editing. But this is the first ACR function I've found that I can't replicate in Lightroom. Hopefully someone will tell me differently. And I should add, when my brother shoots RAW he says that no matter what he does in ACR, cropped or otherwise, he just resized to 24MP's automatically before editing. With the image I used in the video I decided to take a shot and upsize a cropped D7000 image to D800 size (36MP), and the truth is I could have easily used it as a starting point for my editing. I would never consider doing that level of resizing for all my D600 and D7100 shots now, but I'm just glad that I haven't dived head first in to my Yosemite Park re-editing project, where I have a bunch of D7000 and D90 images that deserve a second edit with 3 more years' experience under my belt. I may actually be able to print that 16x20 landscape over the fireplace now. LOL [/QUOTE]

Verification