Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Fortkentdad" data-source="post: 618191" data-attributes="member: 24285">Slept on it - chat with my wife who has been reading the &quot;PhoDOGraphy&quot; book I bought last week - I get to read it when she is done. In the book she tells me the author recommends shooting dogs wide - and since she shoots with the D5100 maybe I should just get a good ultrawide AFC lens.&nbsp; We do have the 16-85 3.5-5.6 that she uses - that is wide, but not ultra. Pulled up a DXO DX Ultrawide comparison <a href="https://www.dxomark.com/Reviews/Tokina-AT-X-11-20mm-f-2.8-Pro-DX-Wonderfully-wide/Comparison-Tokina-11-20mm-f-2.8-vs-Nikon-10-24mm-f-3.5-4.5-vs-Sigma-10-20mm-f-3.5" target="_blank">https://www.dxomark.com/Reviews/Tokina-AT-X-11-20mm-f-2.8-Pro-DX-Wonderfully-wide/Comparison-Tokina-11-20mm-f-2.8-vs-Nikon-10-24mm-f-3.5-4.5-vs-Sigma-10-20mm-f-3.5</a> ALL the top runners are Tokina - which I've heard a few times in this discussion. [ATTACH]252656[/ATTACH]The Siggy 10-20 is the least expensive on sale for $550 and scores 18 vs the top runner - the Tokina 11-20 at 20 - but that's close.&nbsp; None of these come close to the Prime on a FX which scores over 30 - on a DX (D7100) it still hits 23.&nbsp; Maybe I'll HAVE to get both the 20mm prime for me and an ultra-wide DX for her . . .</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Fortkentdad, post: 618191, member: 24285"] Slept on it - chat with my wife who has been reading the "PhoDOGraphy" book I bought last week - I get to read it when she is done. In the book she tells me the author recommends shooting dogs wide - and since she shoots with the D5100 maybe I should just get a good ultrawide AFC lens. We do have the 16-85 3.5-5.6 that she uses - that is wide, but not ultra. Pulled up a DXO DX Ultrawide comparison [URL]https://www.dxomark.com/Reviews/Tokina-AT-X-11-20mm-f-2.8-Pro-DX-Wonderfully-wide/Comparison-Tokina-11-20mm-f-2.8-vs-Nikon-10-24mm-f-3.5-4.5-vs-Sigma-10-20mm-f-3.5[/URL] ALL the top runners are Tokina - which I've heard a few times in this discussion. [ATTACH=CONFIG]252656._xfImport[/ATTACH] The Siggy 10-20 is the least expensive on sale for $550 and scores 18 vs the top runner - the Tokina 11-20 at 20 - but that's close. None of these come close to the Prime on a FX which scores over 30 - on a DX (D7100) it still hits 23. Maybe I'll HAVE to get both the 20mm prime for me and an ultra-wide DX for her . . . [/QUOTE]

Verification