Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="grandpaw" data-source="post: 162127" data-attributes="member: 8635"><p>I am more of an optimistic person than one that goes toward the negative. If I am reading this correctly basically you start out with 12 points and all categories are treated equally and carry the same amount of weight. Basically you were able to keep the one point for that category or it is taken away as a -1. As an example...... For starters if you do a good job on lighting you get to keep your one point that you started with. There again if you really went out of your way and spent an extensive amount of time setting up the lighting and invested hours of time in the setup you get to keep the same one point. I see no way to score additional points for any one of the twelve categories you are to grade on. So basically you get a point or you get one taken away so my choice in grading each category is pretty much I like it or I didn't. I know this is what was chosen and that is fine but I just wanted to give you my thoughts on the system. In each and every photo the amount of importance each of these categories can very greatly but their value is always basically one point yeah or nay. I just don't get it.</p></blockquote><p></p>

[QUOTE="grandpaw, post: 162127, member: 8635"] I am more of an optimistic person than one that goes toward the negative. If I am reading this correctly basically you start out with 12 points and all categories are treated equally and carry the same amount of weight. Basically you were able to keep the one point for that category or it is taken away as a -1. As an example...... For starters if you do a good job on lighting you get to keep your one point that you started with. There again if you really went out of your way and spent an extensive amount of time setting up the lighting and invested hours of time in the setup you get to keep the same one point. I see no way to score additional points for any one of the twelve categories you are to grade on. So basically you get a point or you get one taken away so my choice in grading each category is pretty much I like it or I didn't. I know this is what was chosen and that is fine but I just wanted to give you my thoughts on the system. In each and every photo the amount of importance each of these categories can very greatly but their value is always basically one point yeah or nay. I just don't get it. [/QUOTE]

Verification