Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="WhiteLight" data-source="post: 162108" data-attributes="member: 9556">We've seen some debate about the photo critique section &amp; it's merits and demerits...Am thinking out loud here, not sure if this is feasible at all-can we make the critique section like a feedback form for both posters &amp; reviewers?The requirements for the poster would be like only a single image upload &amp; posting exif data etc. in preset data fields so posters can only post a single image...also posts without the required fields would not be complete, so the system won't allow the uploadeverything that needs to be there..similarly for the reviewers too, a form with the 12 points &amp; space for each of them.At least it would make it easier for folks who take the trouble to give a critique.The score can be automatically calculated as well based on the input.to add- there could be a small comments section for those who want to give a couple of lines feedback.That can either be sent as a message to the poster or just upload into the thread as a comment than as a normal feedback..this could possibly be a way to ensure a perfectly working critique section.Well, that's just my thoughts.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="WhiteLight, post: 162108, member: 9556"] We've seen some debate about the photo critique section & it's merits and demerits... Am thinking out loud here, not sure if this is feasible at all- can we make the critique section like a feedback form for both posters & reviewers? The requirements for the poster would be like only a single image upload & posting exif data etc. in preset data fields so posters can only post a single image... also posts without the required fields would not be complete, so the system won't allow the upload everything that needs to be there.. similarly for the reviewers too, a form with the 12 points & space for each of them. At least it would make it easier for folks who take the trouble to give a critique. The score can be automatically calculated as well based on the input. to add- there could be a small comments section for those who want to give a couple of lines feedback. That can either be sent as a message to the poster or just upload into the thread as a comment than as a normal feedback.. this could possibly be a way to ensure a perfectly working critique section. Well, that's just my thoughts. [/QUOTE]

Verification