Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
New media
New media comments
New profile posts
Latest activity
Media
New media
New comments
Search media
Members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
New posts
Search forums
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Lenses
General Lenses
Odd Distortion in 18-55mm “Kit Lens” on D3200 — Is This Normal?
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Bob Blaylock" data-source="post: 211748" data-attributes="member: 16749"><p>Nikon D3200, with the stock 18-55mm ƒ3.5-5.6 “kit lens”.</p><p></p><p>A short time ago, I took this picture of a dandelion seed head. I was rather alarmed to see the way it came out distorted.</p><p></p><p>[ATTACH]57289[/ATTACH]</p><p></p><p> I was able to fix it in PhotoShop:</p><p></p><p>[ATTACH]57290[/ATTACH]</p><p></p><p> A few attempts, just now, to reproduce this distortion by taking a few other pictures at similar range were not successful. It seems like something odd and irreproducible that happened just on this one occasion.</p><p></p><p> Is there anything useful or otherwise interesting that anyone can tell me about this? Is there any normal, credible or why it would only do so explanation as to why this lens would ever produce this sort of distortion? Why only this once, and not when I later try to reproduce the effect? Is there any reason to fear that this might indicate something wrong with my lens or my camera?</p><p></p><p> How might I be able to reproduce this effect?</p><p></p><p> How might I be able to prevent it?</p><p></p><p> It occurs to me now, that if the dandelion were in very rapid motion, this is the sort of distortion that a focal plane shutter would produce via the “rolling shutter” effect. But the dandelion was not in such motion. I was in a rather unstable position when I took this picture, so I might not have been holding the camera quite as solidly still as I would like. Is it plausible that this is a result of ordinary camera shake? The shutter speed was 1/500 of a second.</p><p></p><p> Here are the EXIF data from the original image file:</p><p></p><p>[code]ExifTool Version Number : 9.37</p><p>File Name : CSC_4977.JPG</p><p>Directory : .</p><p>File Size : 11 MB</p><p>File Modification Date/Time : 2013:10:25 15:42:38-07:00</p><p>File Access Date/Time : 2013:10:25 00:00:00-07:00</p><p>File Inode Change Date/Time : 2013:10:25 15:42:38-07:00</p><p>File Permissions : rwxrwxrwx</p><p>File Type : JPEG</p><p>MIME Type : image/jpeg</p><p>Exif Byte Order : Big-endian (Motorola, MM)</p><p>Make : NIKON CORPORATION</p><p>Camera Model Name : NIKON D3200</p><p>Orientation : Horizontal (normal)</p><p>X Resolution : 300</p><p>Y Resolution : 300</p><p>Resolution Unit : inches</p><p>Software : Ver.1.01</p><p>Modify Date : 2013:10:25 15:42:38</p><p>Y Cb Cr Positioning : Co-sited</p><p>Exposure Time : 1/500</p><p>F Number : 8.0</p><p>Exposure Program : Not Defined</p><p>ISO : 100</p><p>Sensitivity Type : Recommended Exposure Index</p><p>Exif Version : 0230</p><p>Date/Time Original : 2013:10:25 14:57:46</p><p>Create Date : 2013:10:25 15:42:38</p><p>Components Configuration : Y, Cb, Cr, -</p><p>Compressed Bits Per Pixel : 4</p><p>Exposure Compensation : 0</p><p>Max Aperture Value : 5.7</p><p>Metering Mode : Multi-segment</p><p>Light Source : Unknown</p><p>Flash : Auto, Did not fire</p><p>Focal Length : 55.0 mm</p><p>Maker Note Version : 2.10</p><p>Quality : Fine</p><p>White Balance : Auto</p><p>Focus Mode : AF-A</p><p>Flash Setting : </p><p>Flash Type : </p><p>White Balance Fine Tune : 0 0</p><p>WB RB Levels : 1.9296875 1.35546875 1 1</p><p>Program Shift : 0</p><p>Exposure Difference : 0</p><p>Compression : JPEG (old-style)</p><p>Preview Image Start : 13956</p><p>Preview Image Length : 24465</p><p>Flash Exposure Compensation : 0</p><p>ISO Setting : 100</p><p>Image Boundary : 0 0 6016 4000</p><p>External Flash Exposure Comp : 0</p><p>Flash Exposure Bracket Value : 0.0</p><p>Exposure Bracket Value : 0</p><p>Crop Hi Speed : Off (6080x4012 cropped to 6080x4012 at pixel 0,0)</p><p>Exposure Tuning : 0</p><p>Serial Number : 3196964</p><p>VR Info Version : 0100</p><p>Vibration Reduction : On</p><p>VR Mode : Normal</p><p>Active D-Lighting : Auto</p><p>Picture Control Version : 0100</p><p>Picture Control Name : Vivid</p><p>Picture Control Base : Vivid</p><p>Picture Control Adjust : Full Control</p><p>Picture Control Quick Adjust : +2</p><p>Brightness : +1</p><p>Hue Adjustment : None</p><p>Filter Effect : n/a</p><p>Toning Effect : n/a</p><p>Toning Saturation : n/a</p><p>Timezone : -08:00</p><p>Daylight Savings : Yes</p><p>Date Display Format : Y/M/D</p><p>ISO Expansion : Off</p><p>ISO2 : 100</p><p>ISO Expansion 2 : Off</p><p>Auto Distortion Control : Off</p><p>Lens Type : G VR</p><p>Lens : 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6</p><p>Flash Mode : Did Not Fire</p><p>Shooting Mode : Single-Frame</p><p>Shot Info Version : 0224</p><p>Firmware Version : 1.01a</p><p>Noise Reduction : Off</p><p>WB GRBG Levels : 256 494 347 256</p><p>Lens Data Version : 0204</p><p>Exit Pupil Position : 97.5 mm</p><p>AF Aperture : 5.8</p><p>Focus Position : 0x11</p><p>Focus Distance : 0.32 m</p><p>Lens ID Number : 154</p><p>Lens F Stops : 5.33</p><p>Min Focal Length : 18.3 mm</p><p>Max Focal Length : 55.0 mm</p><p>Max Aperture At Min Focal : 3.6</p><p>Max Aperture At Max Focal : 5.7</p><p>MCU Version : 156</p><p>Effective Max Aperture : 5.7</p><p>Retouch History : NEF Processing</p><p>Image Data Size : 11069874</p><p>Shutter Count : 7158</p><p>Flash Info Version : 0105</p><p>Flash Source : None</p><p>External Flash Firmware : n/a</p><p>External Flash Flags : (none)</p><p>Flash Commander Mode : Off</p><p>Flash Control Mode : Off</p><p>Flash Compensation : 0</p><p>Flash GN Distance : 0</p><p>Flash Color Filter : None</p><p>Flash Group A Control Mode : Off</p><p>Flash Group B Control Mode : Off</p><p>Flash Group C Control Mode : Off</p><p>Flash Group A Compensation : 0</p><p>Flash Group B Compensation : 0</p><p>Flash Group C Compensation : 0</p><p>External Flash Compensation : 0</p><p>Flash Exposure Comp 3 : 0</p><p>Flash Exposure Comp 4 : 0</p><p>Vari Program : Close Up</p><p>Multi Exposure Version : 0100</p><p>Multi Exposure Mode : Off</p><p>Multi Exposure Shots : 0</p><p>Multi Exposure Auto Gain : Off</p><p>High ISO Noise Reduction : Normal</p><p>Power Up Time : 2013:10:25 14:13:30</p><p>AF Info 2 Version : 0100</p><p>Contrast Detect AF : Off</p><p>AF Area Mode : Single Area</p><p>Phase Detect AF : On (11-point)</p><p>Primary AF Point : Center</p><p>AF Points Used : Center</p><p>Contrast Detect AF In Focus : No</p><p>File Info Version : 0100</p><p>Directory Number : 100</p><p>File Number : 4977</p><p>User Comment : Bob Blaylock</p><p>Sub Sec Time : 00</p><p>Sub Sec Time Original : 00</p><p>Sub Sec Time Digitized : 00</p><p>Flashpix Version : 0100</p><p>Color Space : sRGB</p><p>Exif Image Width : 6016</p><p>Exif Image Height : 4000</p><p>Interoperability Index : R98 - DCF basic file (sRGB)</p><p>Interoperability Version : 0100</p><p>Sensing Method : One-chip color area</p><p>File Source : Digital Camera</p><p>Scene Type : Directly photographed</p><p>CFA Pattern : [Red,Green][Green,Blue]</p><p>Custom Rendered : Normal</p><p>Exposure Mode : Auto</p><p>Digital Zoom Ratio : 1</p><p>Focal Length In 35mm Format : 82 mm</p><p>Scene Capture Type : Standard</p><p>Gain Control : None</p><p>Contrast : Normal</p><p>Saturation : High</p><p>Sharpness : Hard</p><p>Subject Distance Range : Unknown</p><p>GPS Version ID : 2.3.0.0</p><p>GPS Latitude Ref : North</p><p>GPS Longitude Ref : West</p><p>GPS Altitude Ref : Above Sea Level</p><p>GPS Time Stamp : 21:57:46</p><p>GPS Satellites : 07</p><p>GPS Map Datum : </p><p>GPS Date Stamp : 2013:10:25</p><p>Thumbnail Offset : 38812</p><p>Thumbnail Length : 8403</p><p>MPF Version : 0100</p><p>Number Of Images : 2</p><p>MP Image Flags : Dependent child image</p><p>MP Image Format : JPEG</p><p>MP Image Type : Large Thumbnail (full HD equivalent)</p><p>MP Image Length : 789786</p><p>MP Image Start : 11142144</p><p>Dependent Image 1 Entry Number : 0</p><p>Dependent Image 2 Entry Number : 0</p><p>Image Width : 6016</p><p>Image Height : 4000</p><p>Encoding Process : Baseline DCT, Huffman coding</p><p>Bits Per Sample : 8</p><p>Color Components : 3</p><p>Y Cb Cr Sub Sampling : YCbCr4:2:2 (2 1)</p><p>Aperture : 8.0</p><p>Auto Focus : On</p><p>Blue Balance : 1.355469</p><p>GPS Altitude : 19 m Above Sea Level</p><p>GPS Date/Time : 2013:10:25 21:57:46Z</p><p>GPS Latitude : 38 deg 27' 5.08" N</p><p>GPS Longitude : 121 deg 25' 1.24" W</p><p>GPS Position : 38 deg 27' 5.08" N, 121 deg 25' 1.24" W</p><p>Image Size : 6016x4000</p><p>Lens ID : AF-S DX VR Zoom-Nikkor 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6G</p><p>Lens : 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 G VR</p><p>Preview Image : (Binary data 24465 bytes, use -b option to extract)</p><p>Red Balance : 1.929688</p><p>Scale Factor To 35 mm Equivalent: 1.5</p><p>Shutter Speed : 1/500</p><p>Create Date : 2013:10:25 15:42:38.00</p><p>Date/Time Original : 2013:10:25 14:57:46.00</p><p>Modify Date : 2013:10:25 15:42:38.00</p><p>Thumbnail Image : (Binary data 8403 bytes, use -b option to extract)</p><p>Circle Of Confusion : 0.020 mm</p><p>Depth Of Field : 0.009 m (0.312 - 0.321)</p><p>Field Of View : 20.6 deg (0.11 m)</p><p>Focal Length : 55.0 mm (35 mm equivalent: 82.0 mm)</p><p>Hyperfocal Distance : 18.76 m</p><p>Light Value : 15.0[/code]</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Bob Blaylock, post: 211748, member: 16749"] Nikon D3200, with the stock 18-55mm ƒ3.5-5.6 “kit lens”. A short time ago, I took this picture of a dandelion seed head. I was rather alarmed to see the way it came out distorted. [ATTACH=CONFIG]57289._xfImport[/ATTACH] I was able to fix it in PhotoShop: [ATTACH=CONFIG]57290._xfImport[/ATTACH] A few attempts, just now, to reproduce this distortion by taking a few other pictures at similar range were not successful. It seems like something odd and irreproducible that happened just on this one occasion. Is there anything useful or otherwise interesting that anyone can tell me about this? Is there any normal, credible or why it would only do so explanation as to why this lens would ever produce this sort of distortion? Why only this once, and not when I later try to reproduce the effect? Is there any reason to fear that this might indicate something wrong with my lens or my camera? How might I be able to reproduce this effect? How might I be able to prevent it? It occurs to me now, that if the dandelion were in very rapid motion, this is the sort of distortion that a focal plane shutter would produce via the “rolling shutter” effect. But the dandelion was not in such motion. I was in a rather unstable position when I took this picture, so I might not have been holding the camera quite as solidly still as I would like. Is it plausible that this is a result of ordinary camera shake? The shutter speed was 1/500 of a second. Here are the EXIF data from the original image file: [code]ExifTool Version Number : 9.37 File Name : CSC_4977.JPG Directory : . File Size : 11 MB File Modification Date/Time : 2013:10:25 15:42:38-07:00 File Access Date/Time : 2013:10:25 00:00:00-07:00 File Inode Change Date/Time : 2013:10:25 15:42:38-07:00 File Permissions : rwxrwxrwx File Type : JPEG MIME Type : image/jpeg Exif Byte Order : Big-endian (Motorola, MM) Make : NIKON CORPORATION Camera Model Name : NIKON D3200 Orientation : Horizontal (normal) X Resolution : 300 Y Resolution : 300 Resolution Unit : inches Software : Ver.1.01 Modify Date : 2013:10:25 15:42:38 Y Cb Cr Positioning : Co-sited Exposure Time : 1/500 F Number : 8.0 Exposure Program : Not Defined ISO : 100 Sensitivity Type : Recommended Exposure Index Exif Version : 0230 Date/Time Original : 2013:10:25 14:57:46 Create Date : 2013:10:25 15:42:38 Components Configuration : Y, Cb, Cr, - Compressed Bits Per Pixel : 4 Exposure Compensation : 0 Max Aperture Value : 5.7 Metering Mode : Multi-segment Light Source : Unknown Flash : Auto, Did not fire Focal Length : 55.0 mm Maker Note Version : 2.10 Quality : Fine White Balance : Auto Focus Mode : AF-A Flash Setting : Flash Type : White Balance Fine Tune : 0 0 WB RB Levels : 1.9296875 1.35546875 1 1 Program Shift : 0 Exposure Difference : 0 Compression : JPEG (old-style) Preview Image Start : 13956 Preview Image Length : 24465 Flash Exposure Compensation : 0 ISO Setting : 100 Image Boundary : 0 0 6016 4000 External Flash Exposure Comp : 0 Flash Exposure Bracket Value : 0.0 Exposure Bracket Value : 0 Crop Hi Speed : Off (6080x4012 cropped to 6080x4012 at pixel 0,0) Exposure Tuning : 0 Serial Number : 3196964 VR Info Version : 0100 Vibration Reduction : On VR Mode : Normal Active D-Lighting : Auto Picture Control Version : 0100 Picture Control Name : Vivid Picture Control Base : Vivid Picture Control Adjust : Full Control Picture Control Quick Adjust : +2 Brightness : +1 Hue Adjustment : None Filter Effect : n/a Toning Effect : n/a Toning Saturation : n/a Timezone : -08:00 Daylight Savings : Yes Date Display Format : Y/M/D ISO Expansion : Off ISO2 : 100 ISO Expansion 2 : Off Auto Distortion Control : Off Lens Type : G VR Lens : 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 Flash Mode : Did Not Fire Shooting Mode : Single-Frame Shot Info Version : 0224 Firmware Version : 1.01a Noise Reduction : Off WB GRBG Levels : 256 494 347 256 Lens Data Version : 0204 Exit Pupil Position : 97.5 mm AF Aperture : 5.8 Focus Position : 0x11 Focus Distance : 0.32 m Lens ID Number : 154 Lens F Stops : 5.33 Min Focal Length : 18.3 mm Max Focal Length : 55.0 mm Max Aperture At Min Focal : 3.6 Max Aperture At Max Focal : 5.7 MCU Version : 156 Effective Max Aperture : 5.7 Retouch History : NEF Processing Image Data Size : 11069874 Shutter Count : 7158 Flash Info Version : 0105 Flash Source : None External Flash Firmware : n/a External Flash Flags : (none) Flash Commander Mode : Off Flash Control Mode : Off Flash Compensation : 0 Flash GN Distance : 0 Flash Color Filter : None Flash Group A Control Mode : Off Flash Group B Control Mode : Off Flash Group C Control Mode : Off Flash Group A Compensation : 0 Flash Group B Compensation : 0 Flash Group C Compensation : 0 External Flash Compensation : 0 Flash Exposure Comp 3 : 0 Flash Exposure Comp 4 : 0 Vari Program : Close Up Multi Exposure Version : 0100 Multi Exposure Mode : Off Multi Exposure Shots : 0 Multi Exposure Auto Gain : Off High ISO Noise Reduction : Normal Power Up Time : 2013:10:25 14:13:30 AF Info 2 Version : 0100 Contrast Detect AF : Off AF Area Mode : Single Area Phase Detect AF : On (11-point) Primary AF Point : Center AF Points Used : Center Contrast Detect AF In Focus : No File Info Version : 0100 Directory Number : 100 File Number : 4977 User Comment : Bob Blaylock Sub Sec Time : 00 Sub Sec Time Original : 00 Sub Sec Time Digitized : 00 Flashpix Version : 0100 Color Space : sRGB Exif Image Width : 6016 Exif Image Height : 4000 Interoperability Index : R98 - DCF basic file (sRGB) Interoperability Version : 0100 Sensing Method : One-chip color area File Source : Digital Camera Scene Type : Directly photographed CFA Pattern : [Red,Green][Green,Blue] Custom Rendered : Normal Exposure Mode : Auto Digital Zoom Ratio : 1 Focal Length In 35mm Format : 82 mm Scene Capture Type : Standard Gain Control : None Contrast : Normal Saturation : High Sharpness : Hard Subject Distance Range : Unknown GPS Version ID : 2.3.0.0 GPS Latitude Ref : North GPS Longitude Ref : West GPS Altitude Ref : Above Sea Level GPS Time Stamp : 21:57:46 GPS Satellites : 07 GPS Map Datum : GPS Date Stamp : 2013:10:25 Thumbnail Offset : 38812 Thumbnail Length : 8403 MPF Version : 0100 Number Of Images : 2 MP Image Flags : Dependent child image MP Image Format : JPEG MP Image Type : Large Thumbnail (full HD equivalent) MP Image Length : 789786 MP Image Start : 11142144 Dependent Image 1 Entry Number : 0 Dependent Image 2 Entry Number : 0 Image Width : 6016 Image Height : 4000 Encoding Process : Baseline DCT, Huffman coding Bits Per Sample : 8 Color Components : 3 Y Cb Cr Sub Sampling : YCbCr4:2:2 (2 1) Aperture : 8.0 Auto Focus : On Blue Balance : 1.355469 GPS Altitude : 19 m Above Sea Level GPS Date/Time : 2013:10:25 21:57:46Z GPS Latitude : 38 deg 27' 5.08" N GPS Longitude : 121 deg 25' 1.24" W GPS Position : 38 deg 27' 5.08" N, 121 deg 25' 1.24" W Image Size : 6016x4000 Lens ID : AF-S DX VR Zoom-Nikkor 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6G Lens : 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 G VR Preview Image : (Binary data 24465 bytes, use -b option to extract) Red Balance : 1.929688 Scale Factor To 35 mm Equivalent: 1.5 Shutter Speed : 1/500 Create Date : 2013:10:25 15:42:38.00 Date/Time Original : 2013:10:25 14:57:46.00 Modify Date : 2013:10:25 15:42:38.00 Thumbnail Image : (Binary data 8403 bytes, use -b option to extract) Circle Of Confusion : 0.020 mm Depth Of Field : 0.009 m (0.312 - 0.321) Field Of View : 20.6 deg (0.11 m) Focal Length : 55.0 mm (35 mm equivalent: 82.0 mm) Hyperfocal Distance : 18.76 m Light Value : 15.0[/code] [/QUOTE]
Verification
Post reply
Forums
Lenses
General Lenses
Odd Distortion in 18-55mm “Kit Lens” on D3200 — Is This Normal?
Top