Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="ohkphoto" data-source="post: 62774" data-attributes="member: 1573">There is more than one thread (Check out the daily photos and project365, etc.) . . . many perfect places for casual posting of photos for casual comments.I like the current rules because everyone uses the same standard . . . the 12 points is easy enough to come up with a score.&nbsp; Start with 12 and -1 for what doesn't apply.&nbsp; or start with 0 and +1 for what does apply.&nbsp; simply posting, &quot;really nice work&quot; is not a critique and certainly does not help the poster.I've asked the other mods if anything needed to be changed in the rules and did not get any feedback, so we're leaving it as is, because a lot of thought and effort went into coming up with this system which would be meaningful and educational if everyone gave it a chance.&nbsp; it's a learning experience and no one is ever too old or too perfect to learn something new.As of right now, please read the rules, again.&nbsp; There are rules for the one posting the photo and for the one critiquing.&nbsp; We've rehashed this several times on the forum and everyone had a chance to comment BEFORE it was put into place. So, please follow the rules so I don't have to delete posts.&nbsp; Thank you.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="ohkphoto, post: 62774, member: 1573"] There is more than one thread (Check out the daily photos and project365, etc.) . . . many perfect places for casual posting of photos for casual comments. I like the current rules because everyone uses the same standard . . . the 12 points is easy enough to come up with a score. Start with 12 and -1 for what doesn't apply. or start with 0 and +1 for what does apply. simply posting, "really nice work" is not a critique and certainly does not help the poster. I've asked the other mods if anything needed to be changed in the rules and did not get any feedback, so we're leaving it as is, because a lot of thought and effort went into coming up with this system which would be meaningful and educational if everyone gave it a chance. it's a learning experience and no one is ever too old or too perfect to learn something new. [B]As of right now, please read the rules, again. There are rules for the one posting the photo and for the one critiquing. We've rehashed this several times on the forum and everyone had a chance to comment BEFORE it was put into place. [/B] So, please follow the rules so I don't have to delete posts. Thank you. [/QUOTE]

Verification