Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="rocketman122" data-source="post: 436151" data-attributes="member: 14443">if you dont like your tamron 150-600, I dont think the sigma will be any different. MAYBE slightly if any or possibly not at all. as J-see recommended, try doing an AF tune. I only rethe 80-400 AFS-the new G lens? reviews say its great. if its the gen 1, ask Scott, he has it.if it were me, like Rick, the choice would be very easy. 300mm f/4 AFS gen 1 with TC. no hesitation.&nbsp;dont know why people forget how good the older gen lens is once a new one comes out. its like &quot;thank god we finally have this lens nikon because the other was just a POS&quot; there was a reason why this lens has been around for 15 years. well maybe 5 years too much but its that good. its fast and its brilliant. I think the new PF is overpriced for the minute increase in IQ and no tripod collar as well. but if you have the money and the size is a turn off then go for the PF.Nasims test shows the mtf sharper by a smidge at open (in the center only-corners GEN 1 is superior!) with the new PF but the gen 1 is no slouch as is and paying so much more for a minute difference seems unnecessary. <a href="https://photographylife.com/reviews/nikon-300mm-f4e-pf-ed-vr/3" target="_blank">https://photographylife.com/reviews/nikon-300mm-f4e-pf-ed-vr/3</a></blockquote>

[QUOTE="rocketman122, post: 436151, member: 14443"] if you dont like your tamron 150-600, I dont think the sigma will be any different. MAYBE slightly if any or possibly not at all. as J-see recommended, try doing an AF tune. I only re the 80-400 AFS-the new G lens? reviews say its great. if its the gen 1, ask Scott, he has it. if it were me, like Rick, the choice would be very easy. 300mm f/4 AFS gen 1 with TC. no hesitation. dont know why people forget how good the older gen lens is once a new one comes out. its like "thank god we finally have this lens nikon because the other was just a POS" there was a reason why this lens has been around for 15 years. well maybe 5 years too much but its that good. its fast and its brilliant. I think the new PF is overpriced for the minute increase in IQ and no tripod collar as well. but if you have the money and the size is a turn off then go for the PF. Nasims test shows the mtf sharper by a smidge at open (in the center only-corners GEN 1 is superior!) with the new PF but the gen 1 is no slouch as is and paying so much more for a minute difference seems unnecessary. [url]https://photographylife.com/reviews/nikon-300mm-f4e-pf-ed-vr/3[/url] [/QUOTE]

Verification