My 10-stop and VND went out for a test drive yesterday.

480sparky

Senior Member
Took a bit of time yesterday and took my two new NDs (B+W 10-stop and Singh-Ray VND) out for a test drive. Since we don't have a lot of waterfalls here in Cornpatch, I used the next-best thing.... fountains.

First off, I like to find the 'sweet spot' of my lenses, and try to shoot at that aperture if at all possible. Result: f/11 at 1/125, even at ISO 50 (Low -1.0)

f111125.jpg


Not very silky. Without an ND, the slowest shutter speed possible would be 1/30 when I dial the aperture down to f/22:

f22130.jpg


Getting a little blur, but not near enough to make anything 'silky'. Enter the NDs. Tossing on the B+W 10-stop, and going back to my preferred f/11, I can now set the shutter to 10 seconds... even in broad daylight!

f1110sec.jpg


Oooooooooooh, yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah!





Kitty-corner across the intersection is another fountain, so I tried the Signh-Ray VND there. I set the camera back to ISO 100 and used f/11 (my two preferred settings). Without a filter, I got 1/30 sec.


2NVDf11130.jpg


Toss on the S-R VND, and starting at minimum:

1/20 sec

3VNDf11120.jpg


Start dialing it down.... 1/13 sec:

4VNDf11113.jpg



1/4 sec:

5VNDf1114.jpg



1.3 seconds:

6VNDf111point3.jpg


And finally, at MAX, 6 seconds!

7VNDf116secs.jpg


I did notice that the images tend to get cooler the more it's dialed down, especially at MAX. Some day I may try to create some profiles for the various settings to make corrections a 1-click process.

These two filters are gonna allow me to use ISO 100 and f/11 far more often, letting me match the shutter speed to the subject instead of the sun.
 

STM

Senior Member
Having a set of ND filters in the bag is definitely a necessity. I have a 2x, 4x and 8x ND set in 72mm and a set of rectangular ND's and a set of adapters to fit the holders for the rest of my lenses. The 72mm set works perfectly with my 180mm f/2.8 and 85mm f/1.4 and I have a 62-72mm fiter adapter for the 105mm f/1.8, my three standard lenses for outdoor portraiture. I would think, however, that a 10 stop ND filter would a pretty specialized piece of gear though.
 

Mfrankfort

Senior Member
Awesome comparison. I've been thinking about getting a set. I love what it can do with water, but I'm not sure I'm a huge fan of what it does to the fountains. Just my opinion.
 
Top