Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Grumpy Old Bag" data-source="post: 219347" data-attributes="member: 17939">Hi Knawx,I should not be doing this as I am a new junior member. When I see 96 views and no replies I feel obliged to at least try to give some sort of feedback.I guess you shot a pano here, otherwise you cropped out of proportion. The D800 should not give you the kind of noise visible in this image and there is plenty of it in the upper right and upper left of the image.Shooting an image like this is not easy as you have little control in composition. Symmetrical lines would have worked better, whatever you have on the left you should have on the right. The hill on the right that flattens out puts the image in imbalance. The blade of the turbine on the left that sticks out in the middle of nowhere needs to be removed. The structure on the right hand side with the trees and two turbines is,……….. can I call it distracting.I know it is cheating but try cutting the image in half an then mirror it and you will beter understand what I mean.&nbsp; Another option is to try a completely different composition. I like the idea of the silhouettes against the “red” sky, just try different options.Regards,Andre</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Grumpy Old Bag, post: 219347, member: 17939"] Hi Knawx, I should not be doing this as I am a new junior member. When I see 96 views and no replies I feel obliged to at least try to give some sort of feedback. I guess you shot a pano here, otherwise you cropped out of proportion. The D800 should not give you the kind of noise visible in this image and there is plenty of it in the upper right and upper left of the image. Shooting an image like this is not easy as you have little control in composition. Symmetrical lines would have worked better, whatever you have on the left you should have on the right. The hill on the right that flattens out puts the image in imbalance. The blade of the turbine on the left that sticks out in the middle of nowhere needs to be removed. The structure on the right hand side with the trees and two turbines is,……….. can I call it distracting. I know it is cheating but try cutting the image in half an then mirror it and you will beter understand what I mean. Another option is to try a completely different composition. I like the idea of the silhouettes against the “red” sky, just try different options. Regards, Andre [/QUOTE]

Verification