Could use a recommendation before printing a photo

J

JayLefler

Senior Member
I have a photo that has been edited in a couple of different ways. I'm hoping to get some opinions on which you feel is the better picture. This is the first picture that I'm getting printed out and framed, so I'd like to make sure I have the correct color corrections made.

Photo A

big.jpg

Photo B

http://www.jaylefler.com/bigoriginal.jpg

Can you tell me your opinion on the graphic, and also which you prefer?
 

Attachments

  • DSC_0158_mod2.jpg
    DSC_0158_mod2.jpg
    210.1 KB · Views: 225
Last edited:
M

mikew_RIP

Senior Member
On my screen i prefer the second lighter one,but it should please you first its your picture and your memory,have you considered a crop viewing pictures is a very subjective matter my eyes go straight to the tree and then because there is space to the left of it my brain takes a second or two to decide which way to take my eyes instead of straight into the picture they stray to the left of the tree first.
After saying that its a lovely picture and ime not surprised you want it framed.

mike
 
BackdoorArts

BackdoorArts

Senior Member
Greens are oversaturated in A for me, but under in B. Are you using Lightroom? If you're looking to print there's a SoftProofing option that will allow you to evaluate how your photo will reproduce on various printer and paper types. You might need to do some work to find the profiles for what you want, but it will show you areas in the photo that will not reproduce accurately using that printer/paper combination. I suspect most printers might have issues with the first.

Check the Adobe site for tutorials on using SoftProofing if you haven't done it before.
 
BackdoorArts

BackdoorArts

Senior Member
hark said:
I agree. The first is too green, and the second is too little. Is your monitor calibrated so you can determine how a photo will print out?
Click to expand...

A very good point. Calibrating both monitors and using printer profiles is critical if you want a WYSIWYG print solution.
 
D

Don Kuykendall_RIP

RIP :(
PHOTO SUBMISSION RULES
1. Only one photo submission per day (24 hours). We don't want the forum to be monopolized by a single member.

2. Upload one image in your post. If you have a set of images, just provide a text link, either to your member gallery here on Nikonites.com or off-site. If you are unsure how to do this, please ask.

3. Include as much info as possible along with your image:
  • EXIF data
  • Artistic intent/summary of the photo
  • What specifically do you want feedback on?
Photo submissions will be moderated. If the above 3 items are not included along with your photo, your thread will be deleted.
 
J

JayLefler

Senior Member
Tracsoft - Don Kuykendall said:
PHOTO SUBMISSION RULES
1. Only one photo submission per day (24 hours). We don't want the forum to be monopolized by a single member.

2. Upload one image in your post. If you have a set of images, just provide a text link, either to your member gallery here on Nikonites.com or off-site. If you are unsure how to do this, please ask.

3. Include as much info as possible along with your image:
  • EXIF data
  • Artistic intent/summary of the photo
  • What specifically do you want feedback on?
Photo submissions will be moderated. If the above 3 items are not included along with your photo, your thread will be deleted.
Click to expand...

I thought the rules stated I could post an additional picture if I linked it off of my website?
 
D

Don Kuykendall_RIP

RIP :(
JayLefler said:
I thought the rules stated I could post an additional picture if I linked it off of my website?
Click to expand...

. Include as much info as possible along with your image:
  • EXIF data
  • Artistic intent/summary of the photo
  • What specifically do you want feedback on?

This type of post would be better suited to a different section. Maybe set up a thread for your daily photos.
​
 
Top