Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="nickt" data-source="post: 157012" data-attributes="member: 4923">Funny, I was actually going to post a suggestion on this topic when I had some free time, but I will just add to this thread.There are a lot of 'non-conforming' posts in the Photo Critique forum. Usually it is someone just asking for pointers or encouragement or just a quick "do you like it?". Moderators sometimes remove posts and point out the rules. Sometimes people get annoyed. Personally, I avoid the critique forum because I don't feel qualified to submit a photo or comment properly.My suggestion to improve this situation is to expand the focus of the critique forum. Let folks post one or even a small set of pictures and ask for tips or a casual critique. For those that have a really great image and want a formal evaluation from the more experienced members, they could note 'formal critique' in the subject line and follow all the rules to request critique, including adhering to the one image limit. If someone knows their picture is bad they could put 'help' in the subject line. If someone does not read the rules, then most likely they will not bother to type 'formal critique' in the subject and no harm is done. Typing 'formal critique' would serve to attract those familiar with the formal critique process and set the tone for the thread. Using the subject line to define what is wanted would allow beginners and experts to all participate in the same forum without fear of breaking the rules. Alternatively, maybe split the Critique Forum into a Formal Critique and a Casual Critique/Help! forum. I realize there are many places we can post to get advice or casual critique, but having the two forums right next to each other might make it more clear where to post if you are not looking for formal 12pt critique. Mods could also easily move a post to the casual forum if the more strict rules are not followed.</blockquote>

Verification