What Upgrades do I need for Dancers in Motion

Dangerspouse

Senior Member
According to the NikonUSA website on High Speed Synch (HSS), your camera has that function built in. They state you do have to have an advanced enough speedlight ("Using high speed sync mode with your Nikon DSLR (D7000 series and above) and Nikon Speedlight (SB-500 and up) allows you to synchronize the flash to shutter speeds all the way up to the highest speed the camera is capable of. High speed sync works with all exposure modes, and you can use it with a single Speedlight or multiple flash set-ups." Link is here.)

So test it with your strobes, and if they work then you already have the equipment needed.
 

hark

Administrator
Staff member
Super Mod
I don't know if @WayneF or @Horoscope Fish are still around, but they are knowledgeable about flash/strobe.

Personally I don't use HSS so cannot be of help with freezing that way. The way I learned how to freeze motion with flash is to kill the ambient light altogether. Then a flash/strobe is what freezes the motion. However, flash duration is extremely important when freezing motion. Flash duration means the length of time that the flash/strobe's light is visible to illuminate the subject. Some high end strobes can illuminate with a faster speed than a DSLR/Mirrorless. An example would be Broncolor with a flash duration of 1/8000" or faster when used at a low power.

Keep in mind, the ambient light has been completely shut down - usually the body is set to the maximum shutter sync speed, then the aperture and ISO are set to completely black out an ambient image. Camera settings need to be in full manual, not aperture priority. Flash/strobe is also set manually, not TTL.

Some flash/strobe manufacturers will list the T.1 times depending upon the light's output (example - if a flash is set manually for 1/128 power - this is not a measurement in seconds). Generally the lower the flash power, the better to freeze motion. Flash/strobe set to a higher output needs a stronger light that doesn't dissipate nearly as quickly as a lower powered flash/strobe output (meaning stay away from full power).

You might be interested in watching this video to learn a little more about flash duration.

 

hark

Administrator
Staff member
Super Mod
If you want to learn more about freezing motion with flash/strobe, you should search for T.1 flash duration or flash duration.
 

WayneF

Senior Member
Thanks for the mention hark, I appreciate the thought.

High speed photography is kinda a large subject, but with a HSS capable flash (such as the Nikon SB-600, 700, 800, 900 class), HSS should do the dancing job if the camera is on stage with the dancer, within up to maybe 18 feet, or more with high ISO. HSS is NOT a fast flash, it is merely High Speed Sync. It is not technically a flash, but becomes continuous light, being on all the time the shutter duration is open (which looks continuous to the shutter), so continuous is the slowest possible light that cannot stop motion at all. Shutter duration has to be 1/250 second for HSS work, so it looks to humans like a flash, but it is continuous for that duration. Used because continuous has no sync concept, it always "syncs" at any shutter speed. Meaning, like any continuous light, it uses the regular Equivalent Exposures, meaning wide apertures must use a fast camera shutter speed to still be equivalent. You can switch to any Equivalent Exposure with HSS (well, faster than 1/200 or 1/250 to enable HSS). So the HSS flash is NOT AT ALL fast, but you can have the fast shutter speed to help. However, for a fast shutter speed, the lens will be stopped well down, so you won't have much depth of field. If you feel the need to stop down (like in bright sunlight requires it), you can gang 2 or 4 flashes for 1 or 2 more stops down. Each power double can stop down one stop more.

I remember the early McNally books touting Nikon HSS, and his pictures showed him ganging four Nikon flashes in an umbrella for a model in the desert sun. This need was never mentioned in words. :) But indoor lighting is a different easier class.

My site at https://www.scantips.com/lights/flashbasics2b.html explains HSS, and https://www.scantips.com/lights/flashbasics1c3.html has a HSS Guide Number calculator. These flash model manuals in the specifications give the HSS Guide number chart, and for the SB-700 at 50 mm zoom and ISO 100 and 1/500 second, it is 46.6 (feet). My calculator will convert that to other ISO and shutter speeds and show power level for the distance and aperture. But TTL should work too if in range.

You can use the camera meter for HSS, but the Guide Number calculator can give you expectations of possible range ahead of time. The room does not need to be dark for HSS, since both the HSS flash and room lighting is continuous. HSS becomes more a fill flash for the room lighting then (but sunlight is so bright, it sort of overwhelms and needs a stopped down aperture instead of f/2.8 to expose sunlight).


Alternately, (switching to Speedlights), speedlight mode is much faster than camera shutter speed when at low power, but lowest power means the range is short, more like inches than feet (at least if stopped down to f/16 for macro work). These Nikon flash manuals (I think not the SB-500?) give the flash speedlight duration in the specifications.
For the SB-700 it is:

1/1042 sec. at M1/1 (full) output
1/1136 sec. at M1/2 output
1/2857 sec. at M1/4 output
1/5714 sec. at M1/8 output
1/10000 sec. at M1/16 output
1/18182 sec. at M1/32 output
1/25000 sec. at M1/64 output
1/40000 sec. at M1/128 output

And all models are about similar speeds, but not the same exact specifications. So they are called speedlights, because even like a normal 1/2 power is around 1/1000 second. But sunlight at sync speed can still show some motion blur.

Except for the one full power setting (which it is NOT speedlight speed), the speedlight clipping off flash duration for low power makes the others fast which approximate a T1 time, but the shutter speed still has to be 1/250 or 1/200 second to sync, Which is much slower, so that means the room has to be reasonably dim. Not necessary real dark, but a picture there at the same settings with the flash turned off or unplugged should come out black, else the room light can blur the speed. But in practice, just dim works OK and you can still see to work (but test it with that black exposure).

So about 1/32 or 1/64 second works real well for milk drop splashes at f/16, and a 105 mm macro lens keeps it far enough back (a few inches) to not splatter the lens with milk (wise to use a clear filter on it though).

Hope that is of some interest.
Wayne
 
Last edited:

WayneF

Senior Member
Looking at B&H's description for your strobes, it lists Flash Duration: 1/800 to 1/2000 sec. You'd have to play around and see if 1/2000" will be fast enough for the type of dance she will be doing.

https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1341784-REG/godox_sk400ii_400w_monolight_studio.html


That would be a "regular" type studio light, which implements low power by recycling recharge to a lower voltage level. That makes it be a bit "sluggish", only meaning that (the complete opposite of speedlights), low power is slower (longer duration) than maximum power. So the 1/800 second would be minimum power, and 1/2000 would be maximum power. 400 watts seems likely to be too much power for portrait situations, but the dancer would be a further distance and might use much of 400 watts.

Speedlights conversely always recycle recharge to full maximum voltage, but cut the flash off short (shorter duration) to implement lower power. So without the cooler trailing fade-away "tail", this makes their color temperature become less red at low power, where the voltage controlled studio flash type becomes more red at low power. Opposite to the way painter artists think of warm or cool color, physics says blue is a hotter flash than red.

Either type flash does their purpose well, but for either one, different power levels produce different color, so a White Balance card and a Color Temperature tool (click the card area in the first test picture) can easily and perfectly adjust color, which is NOT inconvenient in a fixed portrait setup.
 
Top