Using a tripod with VR turned on

So I've heard many times over that you should not use VR when your camera is set on a tripod and I suppose that also applies to a monopod, because it's counter-productive. In the past I've just taken this as fact because I didn't really understand how VR worked but now that I have a modicum of understanding (a very small modicum, mind you), I don't see why VR would be a bad thing when you're using a tripod. Seems like having the VR floating element released when connected to a tripod would be the same as a very steady handhold, doesn't it?

Does anyone understand why using VR on a tripod is a bad thing?

I have also heard that. I have never done it, but I have heard that you should turn it off. I don't see the issue.

I tend to agree with the conventional wisdom. Anything you can do to reduce vibration is a good thing. So... assuming you have a good, sturdy tripod (this is most important), and assuming you are skilled enough to not jerk the shutter... why would you want to introduce the mechanical vibration (however tiny) of a VR motor if it isn't necessary?

Just my $0.02.

hi to mojo-f-stop. why not put some of your pics in a gallery so we can see the fruits of all your wisdom?

I always leave it on (only because I forget to turn it off when its on a tripod).

ha ha, it will make a little noise when it is activated. by the way, the cannon version will sense if the camera is steady and deactivate itself automatically. come on nikon, get with the program!

I seldom turn mine on but here is a good read I had book marked a while ago:

Nikon VR explained

This is an excellent question and good dialogue. I usually forget to turn it off, also.