Post your church shots

Blue439

New member
Beaulieu-sur-Dodogne (Périgord, southwestern France) Benedictine abbey church. The Ex Libris string trio rehearsing in the transept in preparation for the evening’s concert (2022).

Nikon Z7 II, Micro-Nikkor 85mm, ƒ/2.8 PC-E tilt-shift lens, manual focus, FTZ II adapter. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head. Natural light.

52203776031_e726ff5ef3_o.jpg
 

Blue439

New member
In the abbey church of Beaulieu-sur-Dordogne, Périgord, southwestern France. The stylized letters you see engraved on some stones are marques de tâcherons, or maker’s marks. Stone cutters in the Middle Ages were, like many other trades, paid on a “piecework” basis. With this unique mark they identified the work they had done so that payment could be made without hesitation.

Those marks are also a great way –well, the only way, in truth– to track artisans as they went from one construction site to another.

Beaulieu in the Spring of 2022 was the last place I shot with the Sigma 135mm Art, F-mount, lens. It was a good lens but of course a bit limited in terms of reach... Some of the things I need to shoot in old churches are small and far away! Soon after this, I bought the Nikkor Z 100–400mm zoom, which based on my experience outperforms the Sigma. I never looked back.

Nikon Z7 II, Sigma 135mm, ƒ/1.8 Art lens, FTZ II adapter. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head. Natural light.

52197375158_f5719a2689_o.jpg
 

Blue439

New member
In 2022, I was driving on small, lazy back-country road in the clear light of a June morning in the province of Aquitaine (southwestern France) when I happened, purely by chance, upon this wonderful early Romanesque church built on a hilltop in the middle of nowhere, a few kilometers from the village of Curemonte.

Dedicated to Saint Hilaire (Hillary), this Year 1000 church is referred to as an église-mère (“Mother church”), which is an old way of saying that it was the first church ever built in the area. In fact, archæological research has shown that it is built upon another type of building, possibly a very early Christian baptistry built around the 4th or 5th century, when the region was christianized, or even a Pagan temple of some kind from Gallo-Roman times.

My assessment as an amateur art historian is that the original apse, the three-sided one on the left, is clearly pre-Year 1000 (Carolingian, I would say), while the second, semi-circular one on the right is Romanesque from the early 1000s. It was obviously built later to accommodate a growing congregation.

The walled enclosure behind the church used to be a cemetery, but as I think I mentioned before, most of those cemeteries were decommissioned from the 1870s for public health reasons .

Nikon Z7 II, Nikkor 19mm, ƒ/4 PC-E tilt-shift lens. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head.

52210793556_348ecfdb6d_o.jpg
 
Last edited:

Blue439

New member
A Romanesque masterpiece

Dedicated to Saint Peter and located on the path to Compostela (and therefore a UNESCO World Heritage site), the Benedictine abbey of Moissac in Aquitaine was founded in the 700s. According to legend, it was founded even earlier, in 506, by the freshly converted Clovis, King of the Franks, but there is no historical evidence that this truly was the case. Affiliated to Cluny from 1047, it became the most powerful monastery in southwestern France and numbered over 1,000 monks —most likely including lay brothers, though.

This abbey is renowned worldwide for its architectural and artistic treasures, the most famous parts being the church’s stunning tympanum and the iconic statue of Saint Jeremy. There are stunningly innovative features everywhere (look at those “scalloped” doors!), and the abbey was on the very first list of Historic Landmarks drawn up by Minister Prosper Mérimée in 1840.

Inside the church (the southern portal with its tympanum is to the right) is a narthex with cyclopean diagonal stone arches that support the Mediæval battlements and the bell tower above. In front of you are the two smallish doors into the nave itself.

Nikon Z7 II, Nikkor 19mm, ƒ/4 PC-E tilt-shift lens, manual focus. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head. Natural light.

52212061212_3359040d39_o.jpg
 

Blue439

New member
The Romanesque cloister of the abbey of Moissac (Aquitaine, southwestern France). Built during the early 1100s. You can see that construction uses both brick and stone, and that’s because we’re very close to the large city of Toulouse, where brick could always be produced in large quantities, owing to the ready availability of the raw materials to make it.

You can also see that, in the center of each gallery, there is a large brick pillar, decorated with low relief sculpted stone plates. The sculptures on those plates are famous, as are the historied capitals you can see crowning each column or pair of columns.

Nikon Z7 II, Micro-Nikkor 85mm, ƒ/2.8 PC-E tilt-shift macro lens, manual focus. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head.

52226804905_fa44668bb9_o.jpg
 

Blue439

New member
A ghostly church

Still partly shrouded in mist, the ghost–like ruins of the Romanesque priory church of Notre–Dame d’Aleyrac (Drôme region, southeastern France) slowly emerge into the morning light. A sight I will never forget (2014).

Listed in 1904 as Historic Landmark.

Nikon D3S, Nikkor 24-70mm, ƒ/2.8 G lens. Handheld.

51011734501_8acf3757d4_o.jpg
 

Blue439

New member
The admirable vaulting in the high chapel above the narthex of the Romanesque abbey church of Moissac, southwestern France.

I can just sit there or lie on the floor and gaze at it for hours...

Nikon Z7 II, Nikkor 19mm, ƒ/4 PC-E tilt-shift lens, manual focus. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head. Natural light, single exposure.

52223937101_c8e41c6334_o.jpg
 

Blue439

New member
Author’s pride

This is a very rare example of “author’s pride” at the age of the Romanesque (so, roughly, between 1000 and 1200): a signed capital. One has to understand that, at that time, religion permeated every practical aspect of daily life; thus, people who worked on the erection and decoration of religious buildings were utterly convinced that they worked for and under the watchful eye, of God. Therefore, they were very strongly incited to abide by Christian standards and, say, avoid sinning inasmuch as possible.

Pride being a capital sin, this may explain why the vast majority of the works of art created during that period were not signed. In most cases, we have no clue who designed those magnificent churches or those stunning sculptures. This historied capital is an exception, as it is indeed “signed”.

The small town of Chauvigny in central-southwestern France had a chapter of 10 canons right after Year 1000 (most likely secular canons, as there is no evidence nearby of any cloister or other communal building), but the collegiate church that we see today was not built until the early 1100s. It is dedicated to Saint Peter. Damaged during the Wars of Religion, it was listed as a Historic Landmark as early as 1846 and undertook several campaigns of restoration during the 19th century.

During one of those, in 1856, they thought it would be great to re-paint the inside of the church “just like it must have looked in the Middle Ages”, which is why we have to suffer here too, like in Civaux and unfortunately like many other churches I visited in the old province of Poitou, the gory and cheesy colors and the fake apparel that disfigure the walls, the columns and the capitals.

The decorative program on the capitals includes scenes from the life of Jesus, as well as wild creatures and assorted monsters. This capital here shows Jesus being presented by Mary to the Three Wise Men. However, the reason why it is famous among Mediævalists is because the sculptor has signed his name: Gofridus me fecit, i.e., “Gofridus made me”.

As is almost always the case, and this is one of the great mysteries of the Middle Ages which I already had the occasion to discuss in specialized fora, this Gofridus is not to be found anywhere else on the face of the Earth: he came out of the great big nothingness, having worked nowhere before he was hired to decorate Chauvigny (where did he get his obvious prior experience? no one knows), and after he produced that masterpiece, he dissolved back into the said nothingness and worked nowhere else, even though he now had a major claim to fame and could go on making a very good living as a sculptor in other churches or cloisters that were being built all over France and the rest of Western Europe in the 1100s...

Notice also the hand of God giving the benediction in the upper right hand corner.

Nikon Z7 II, Micro-Nikkor 85mm, ƒ/2.8 PC-E tilt-shift lens, FTZ II adapter, manual focus. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head. Natural light.

52281183532_7e99823fcc_o.jpg
 

Blue439

New member
Two more capitals from the collegiate church of Chauvigny, to illustrate two different aspects of what was expected from this kind of decoration in churches during the Romanesque age.

The first one below is purely didactic. In the Middle Ages, most people, even among the nobility, could not read nor write. Only clerics knew, but also some sculptors who were then not only able to sign their name 😎 , but also to caption their work. This was important because sculpture in general, and capitals in particular, were used to educate the unlearned masses through showing them images. The capital below thus contains a caption that reads Gabriel Archangelus dixit Gloria in excelsis Deo, i.e. “Archangel Gabriel chants Gloria in excelsis Deo”. The canons or the priests could read that caption, so that they would not be mistaken in explaining the image to the parishioners. We are also very lucky that this caption does not contain the sort of abbreviations they were so fond of in the Middle Ages, and which make some writings almost undecipherable!

52280599590_12364f1017_o.jpg



The second capital, below, is a good example of imagination of sculptors running wild, like it so often did in those days. Those guys were amazing at imagining monsters they had never seen (for a good reason!) and at depicting them in full action on the stones! Here, we see sphinxes (or more accurately sphinges), themselves formidable creatures, being attacked by other undefined monsters with humanoid faces that are biting their tails. Biting, swallowing and regurgitating –anything one did with their mouth, indeed– were a big part of symbolism at the time. I have an enormous book on Romanesque symbolism which I haven’t dared attack yet, otherwise I would have been able to explain what the sculptor could have been trying to tell us... stay tuned! :rolleyes:

52282433314_8c5a146ff2_o.jpg


Both photos taken with Nikon Z7 II, Micro-Nikkor 85mm, ƒ/2.8D PC-E tilt-shift lens, manual focus, FTZ II adapter. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head. Natural light.
 
Last edited:

Blue439

New member
The light in the chapel

Of the three Romanesque churches to be found in the city of Poitiers (central western France), Saint-Hilaire-le-Grand is the grandest. In fact, it is one of the most impressive Romanesque churches I have ever seen. Built between, roughly, 1020 and 1070 on the location where Saint Hilaire (bishop of Poitiers around 350) was supposedly buried and on which an oratorium, then several prior churches had been erected, the church was subject to substantial remodeling during the Gothic period, and then during the “restorations” of the 19th century, with some very unfortunate initiatives. Fortunately the inside kept its Romanesque architecture, its atmosphere and its venerable stones —and above all, this magical quality of the light that can only be found in Romanesque churches.

This photo shows one of the radiating chapels built around the apse. Saint-Hilaire-le-Grand is a major pilgrimage church and on the Path to Compostela, therefore it was essential to ensure a smooth circulation of the very dense crowds that came here to venerate the relics of the saint.

Nowadays, it is very quiet around the old stones, but the light is still there for whoever feels the urge to bathe in it...

Nikon Z7 II, Micro-Nikkor 45mm, ƒ/2.8D PC-E tilt-shift lens, manual focus, FTZ II adapter. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head. Natural light.

52292656847_590f41ec1d_o.jpg
 

Blue439

New member
A Mediæval boar hunt (2022)

A very vivid depiction of a boar hunt on a capital in the Romanesque church of Saint Hillary in the village of Melle (western France), on one of the Paths to Compostela, the Via Turonensis that begins in the city of Tours, on the Loire River.

The so-called “fake apparel”, i.e., simulating joints between stones with paint, is typical of the way “restorers” used to like to do things in the 19th century. In this instance like in so many others, restorers are more “inventors”, creating things that never were there but “looked Mediæval” to their eyes.

Nikon Z7 II, Sigma 135mm, ƒ/1.8 E Art lens, FTZ II adapter. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head. Natural light.

52316366708_e2bfa2a869_o.jpg
 

Blue439

New member
The masterpieces of Romanesque sculpture (2022)

This is still the abbey church of Fleury (central France), of which I also posted a couple of photos in the “Post your black-and-white photos” section of the forum.

In the Middle Ages, people from the outside, whether they be parishioners from the village or visitors of the abbey, gained entrance into the church via the northern portal, which was on the side of the hostelry. The monastic enclosure with the cloister was on the southern side. The northern portal is dominated by a splendid tympanum, amazingly sculpted probably during the 1100s. Traces of old polychromy are visible.

This is a representation of Saint Mark in the lower left corner of the Tetramorph, with a seated Jesus partly showing to the right of the frame. The saint looks away from the Christ and towards his symbol (the lion) because, according to tradition, Mark never knew Jesus personally.

The level of expertise displayed in this tympanum is stunning, especially considering the relative crudeness of the tools they had to use at the time. I wish I could upload this in a much larger size like I do on Flickr so you could see how intricate and minute all those details are.

Nikon Z7 II, Sigma 135mm, ƒ/1.8 Art lens, FTZ II adapter. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head. Natural light.


52351760051_7281711dbe_o.jpg
 

Blue439

New member
A Carolingian mosaic (2022)

It is always difficult to write about the history of Romanesque churches, because they are very old, and back in the day, not a lot was written down, and a lot of what was has since then disappeared in the mists of time... Even the major churches are not very well documented sometimes, let alone the smaller ones. The further back one goes in time, the scarcer and more unreliable the written evidence becomes.

The church known today as the Oratory in the village of Germigny-des-Prés near the banks of the Loire in central France, is a good example of that. If we are to trust written History, we know that the church was built there between 803 and 806 by the abbot of Fleury, the abbey where the above photo was taken. So, we are led to believe that there was nothing in that place before. It turns out that couldn’t be more wrong: because the shape of the church (a quatrefoil) and the way the stones were cut intrigued them, some archæologists decided to carry out a non-destructive survey in 2019, which revealed that a lot of the structural walls were in fact from the mid-600s, 150 years before the Carolingian church was built, re-using a number of the pre-existing Merovingian walls...

It is also interesting to note that, although rather small and quite out of the way, this church made it to the very first list of Historic Landmarks of 1840... Its value today is also recognized by a UNESCO World Heritage badge.

The mosaic was covered by whitewash when it was rediscovered in the 1820s, and restored with 6,800 gold-covered glass tesseræ, on an estimated total of 130,000. The motif is the Ark of the Covenant surrounded by two angels. It is typical of the period just after the iconoclastic strife within the Church, when human representation was frowned upon. The Ark with cherubim and angels was safer as a theme... The Byzantine look probably comes from the fact that, in 800, Abbot Theodulf of Fleury, the re-builder of the church in 803, went with Charlemagne to Rome for the latter’s crowning. There, Theodulf saw Byzantinian mosaics in churches and got his inspiration, possibly bringing back with him to Germigny a team of mosaicists.

All shots: Nikon Z7 II, Nikkor 19mm, ƒ/4 PC-E tilt-shift lens, manual focus, FTZ II adapter. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head.


The back of the church:

52382702084_3907a4561d_o.jpg



The chancel and the apse, crowned by the mosaic:

52379080962_c46d846419_o.jpg



The mosaic:

52380254998_b837ebd484_o.jpg
 

Blue439

New member
La Charité: the grandest priory that ever was (2022)

As you know, priories (i.e., subsidiaries of abbeys) usually are humble, smallish-sized affairs. Around 1200, at the end of the Romanesque age, the French abbey of Cluny numbered more than 1,000 of them, but the Cluniac priory in La Charité-sur-Loire (central France) is unique in that it features a more enormous and impressive church than most full-fledged abbeys.

The priory was founded in 1052 by a monk from Cluny named Gérard, on land gifted by the count of Nevers. In 1135, the finished Romanesque church was nothing but the second largest church in Christendom, after Cluny’s major ecclesia itself. Thus, it was dubbed “Cluny’s elder daughter”.

Further to damages and a great fire sustained in 1559 during the Wars of Religion, the church was never fully rebuilt, but substantially remodeled in the 17th century. Not much of what’s left is Romanesque, but what is is grandiose and magnificent, as we can see here.

Listed as a Historic Landmark on the very first list of 1840, it is also a UNESCO World Heritage site, as it is located on the Via Lemovicensis, the path to Compostela originating in Vézelay and going through the large city of Limoges, hence its name.

It is currently undergoing restoration works (roof insulation) funded in part by the Fondation du Patrimoine, one of the non-profit heritage foundations I work for as a pro bono photographer. The photo below was shot as part of a campaign meant to illustrate such works. The photo shows the choir and the apse: “broken” or “pointy” arches typical of Cluniac architecture, three stories, a false triforium and plenty of light coming down from the windows at the clerestory level.

Nikon Z7 II, Nikkor 19mm, ƒ/4 PC-E tilt-shift lens, FTZ II adapter. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head. Natural light. Nik Software’s ColorEfex Pro 4 used during the post-processing.

52386698412_c3228815af_o.jpg
 

Blue439

New member
Another priory church the size of a cathedral (2022)

Not only the Saint-Étienne (Saint Stephen in English) church in the town of Nevers (central France) is super-large for a priory (another of those priories of Cluny, like La Charité pictured above), it is also the very first time in History that builders attempted a three-story high church under a barrel vaulting —a considerable and daring achievement for those times. It was built between 1068 and 1100.

Protected as a Historic Landmark on the very first list of 1840, the church is also part of the Via Lemovicensis Path to Compostela, hence a UNESCO World Heritage site. Little known to anyone outside the circle of Mediævalists, Saint-Étienne of Nevers is one of the best preserved Romanesque churches in France. It looks today, in fact, almost exactly as it did when it was built.

This is a rare and spectacular photograph of the whole length of the nave, as seen from the elevated tribune. I had made arrangements in advance with the city of Nevers so that I would be allowed to access this part of the church out of bounds to the public. From here you can also better see how the transverse arches get more and more deformed, “flattened” by the weight of the vault as you move from East to West along the nave.

Nikon Z7 II, Nikkor 19mm, ƒ/4 PC-E tilt-shift lens, manual focus, FTZ II adapter. Gitzo tripod, Benro geared head. Natural light.

52401051441_e69eb1b269_o.jpg
 
Last edited:
Top