Add a Companion Comment Thread to the Monthy Assignments Thread

Eyelight

Senior Member
I suggest there be a companion thread to each monthly assignment thread, so folks could make public comments like:

Posting photos of a incredibly cute little duckies like @wev did at 6;53pm today is just not fair.:hopelessness:
 

Roy1961

Senior Member
Contributor
ok, read this wrong, shouldnt be a problem then, probably better to name it the same with comments added to it??
 

mikew_RIP

Senior Member
Not sure i see the need for this,although its an assignment it is still a sort of competition and the likes are taken into account by the mods commenting anywhere could effect this,there is plenty of chance to comment after the close date.
 

Mike D90

Senior Member
Not being a hard ass but I just do not understand some peoples inability to withhold posting comments on a photo in an assignment thread. Can one not keep some comments to themselves? Comments clutter the thread and add nothing to the photo as to merit or quality.
 

Eyelight

Senior Member
Not being a hard ass but I just do not understand some peoples inability to withhold posting comments on a photo in an assignment thread. Can one not keep some comments to themselves? Comments clutter the thread and add nothing to the photo as to merit or quality.

The comments I've seen people make, I think they just forget. After all, in cyberspace, the idea of a forum is to discuss. And that is one reason I suggest a separate thread for comments. But I can see @mikew 's point about it influencing the competition. Of course it is a friendly competition and the judge folk would not have to read the comment thread.
 

mikew_RIP

Senior Member
The comments I've seen people make, I think they just forget. After all, in cyberspace, the idea of a forum is to discuss. And that is one reason I suggest a separate thread for comments. But I can see @mikew 's point about it influencing the competition. Of course it is a friendly competition and the judge folk would not have to read the comment thread.


What the mods not look at a thread,never they would think there missing something :D
 

Eyelight

Senior Member
I also thought not all entries would be discussed so some would get unfair publicity

If it were strictly a competition, I agree 100%, but where this goes on for several weeks, there is a lot of variable. We already do the like thing. However, just a suggestion, which didn't get a lot of comments. I probably just need to hit the PM button more often.:)
 
Top