BackdoorArts
Senior Member
I'm sort of tired of people responding to inquiries from someone thinking of buying a D800 and then using it with their current glass with analogies about buying a performance car and then using it with cheap tires, broken engines, you name it. So, I've taken 5 shots here with 5 different lenses that I've spent anywhere between $50 and over $1000. The lenses, in descending order of expense, are...
Nikon 24-120mm f/4
Sigma 24-70mm f/28
Nikon 24-85mm f/3.5-4.5
Nikon 50mm f/1.8
Nikkor 28-80mm f/3.5-5.5
Each was shot in manual mode at f/5.6. Framing of the zooms was approximated by a comparison to the 50mm, and composition (such as it is) was done to show areas of focus and OOF/bokeh. Nothing fancy, just pictures you take with a camera, which is my point in disputing these analogies - most people who buy cameras to take pictures, just like most of the idiots buy Ferraris spend more time sitting in traffic and driving under the speed limit and not on a track.
I've sized these in a way that will hopefully remove the EXIF data on upload.
Your goal, tell me which lens is on the D800 for each shot. If you pass, I will allow you to use your stupid analogy in the future. If you fail, I will taunt you miserably each time you do.
Seriously, though, my point here is not to mock the analogy makers (though I do believe it's a crappy analogy), but to say that for most amateurs serious enough to consider the D800, the arguments about the sensor out performing the glass are only valid for what would likely amount to a miniscule percentage of their photography. For the rest, it's going to take a great photo with whatever you stick on the front, and that's the point. And it gives them something to grow into and not out of as they get more and more serious about their photography.
Nikon 24-120mm f/4
Sigma 24-70mm f/28
Nikon 24-85mm f/3.5-4.5
Nikon 50mm f/1.8
Nikkor 28-80mm f/3.5-5.5
Each was shot in manual mode at f/5.6. Framing of the zooms was approximated by a comparison to the 50mm, and composition (such as it is) was done to show areas of focus and OOF/bokeh. Nothing fancy, just pictures you take with a camera, which is my point in disputing these analogies - most people who buy cameras to take pictures, just like most of the idiots buy Ferraris spend more time sitting in traffic and driving under the speed limit and not on a track.
I've sized these in a way that will hopefully remove the EXIF data on upload.
Your goal, tell me which lens is on the D800 for each shot. If you pass, I will allow you to use your stupid analogy in the future. If you fail, I will taunt you miserably each time you do.
Seriously, though, my point here is not to mock the analogy makers (though I do believe it's a crappy analogy), but to say that for most amateurs serious enough to consider the D800, the arguments about the sensor out performing the glass are only valid for what would likely amount to a miniscule percentage of their photography. For the rest, it's going to take a great photo with whatever you stick on the front, and that's the point. And it gives them something to grow into and not out of as they get more and more serious about their photography.
Last edited:
And no fair trying to drill into the EXIF some way or other.
