Problems with long shutter speed when it gets dark?

Dear Nikonites,

Hello everybody I've joined Nikonites today the 16th of June.

I bought a brand new D7000 in March of this year 2013.

I live near the coast of Pembrokeshire, in Wales, UK and often go out to the local beaches around 1 hour before sunset to get some shots of the sun illuminating the clouds and sea. Colours and atmosphere become very interesting around sunset as I'm sure you all know.

I've just read "Understanding Exposure" the 3rd Edition by Bryan Peterson and last night I decided that I would like to experiment with some longer shutter speed exposures to get that motion blur effect of the waves rolling up the beach. I found that as the ambient light got darker and I wanted to extend the shutter speed up to 30 seconds a message - Job (Nr) - was displayed. What does - Job (Nr) - mean? With the camera in Manual Mode with ISO 200 and f/22 the camera was refusing to take shots.

Does anybody have an explanation for this?

Regards,

Paul.
 

Ima Hack

Senior Member
If I'm taking a long exposure shot, say 20 or 30 seconds, I always see "Job (nr) after the shot has been made, if I wait ten seconds or so the completed image shows up in the display. I believe it takes the camera a few seconds to process the image.
Is this what your're seeing or does an image never appear?
 

RockyNH_RIP

Senior Member
Dear Nikonites,

Hello everybody I've joined Nikonites today the 16th of June.

I bought a brand new D7000 in March of this year 2013.

I live near the coast of Pembrokeshire, in Wales, UK and often go out to the local beaches around 1 hour before sunset to get some shots of the sun illuminating the clouds and sea. Colours and atmosphere become very interesting around sunset as I'm sure you all know.

I've just read "Understanding Exposure" the 3rd Edition by Bryan Peterson and last night I decided that I would like to experiment with some longer shutter speed exposures to get that motion blur effect of the waves rolling up the beach. I found that as the ambient light got darker and I wanted to extend the shutter speed up to 30 seconds a message - Job (Nr) - was displayed. What does - Job (Nr) - mean? With the camera in Manual Mode with ISO 200 and f/22 the camera was refusing to take shots.

Does anybody have an explanation for this?

Regards,

Paul.

Hello Paul,

Welcome to Nikonites...

What you are seeing is an indicator the Long Exposure Noise reduction is now Active. After taking the shot, it will take a 2nd with mirror up to use as a template and try to reduce the noise in your shot. This is explained in more detail in your manual. (You can turn it off if you choose)

I am only guessing, but if it was getting darker out an/or low contrast, your camera may have had trouble focusing... If set to auto, and unable to obtain the focus, it locks out the shutter.

Pat in NH
 

Horoscope Fish

Senior Member
I am only guessing, but if it was getting darker out an/or low contrast, your camera may have had trouble focusing... If set to auto, and unable to obtain the focus, it locks out the shutter.
I agree this is probably the issue you're having since getting a focus-lock in low light situations can be difficult. The solution might be to take a good, powerful, flashlight (torch?) along on these trips. You can't have "too much" power in this situation, I might add... Anyway, you use the flashlight (torch) to "light up" the scene, just so you can get a focus lock, and then shut it off to take the actual shot.

What I do is compose the rough shot with Auto Focus enabled, light up the scene with my flashlight to get the focus-lock, then I shut OFF the Auto Focus, recompose/tweak the framing as needed, then finally pop the shutter. And wait...

As has already been explained, the "job NR" message is your camera telling you it is applying Noise Reduction and that you need to chill out while it does it's crazy, noise-reduction groove-thaaang.

​Hope that helps!
 
Last edited:

nickt

Senior Member
Hello Paul,

What you are seeing is an indicator the Long Exposure Noise reduction is now Active. After taking the shot, it will take a 2nd with mirror up to use as a template and try to reduce the noise in your shot. This is explained in more detail in your manual. (You can turn it off if you choose)
Pat in NH

Pat, I'm not so sure about the 2nd photo for a template. Sounds like you are mixing up with dust reference? I think the NR is strictly a process applied to the single shot and it roughly doubles the time. You can move the camera around after the initial shot during the process time. But if you happen to switch it off, the picture will be saved but not the noise reduction. The mirror might stay up, I forget, but its not taking a second shot.
 

Horoscope Fish

Senior Member
Pat, I'm not so sure about the 2nd photo for a template. Sounds like you are mixing up with dust reference? I think the NR is strictly a process applied to the single shot and it roughly doubles the time. You can move the camera around after the initial shot during the process time. But if you happen to switch it off, the picture will be saved but not the noise reduction. The mirror might stay up, I forget, but its not taking a second shot.
Nikon has this to say about Long Exposure Noise reduction: "[the] Noise Reduction feature will take a “dark frame” (a photo with the shutter closed) after the main image, and then electronically “subtract” the noise from the photograph. Because this second photo is taken, the time from pressing the shutter button until the image is recorded is doubled."




.
 

RockyNH_RIP

Senior Member
Pat, I'm not so sure about the 2nd photo for a template. Sounds like you are mixing up with dust reference? I think the NR is strictly a process applied to the single shot and it roughly doubles the time. You can move the camera around after the initial shot during the process time. But if you happen to switch it off, the picture will be saved but not the noise reduction. The mirror might stay up, I forget, but its not taking a second shot.

Nick,

I was incorrect on the mirror staying up but many sources on the net explain there is a 2nd shot, black (not saved). This states the shot is taken with the shutter closed...

This had come up as a question on the forum a few weeks back which is

Here is one such example....

Nikon knows that their sensors might exhibit more noise than is acceptable in exposures longer than 8 seconds. The sensor can start to warm up a little when longer exposures are used. This causes a condition called amp noise, in which warmer sections of the sensor start to create more noise than cooler sections. There are two settings for Long exp. NR (figure 2):


  • On – When you select On and an exposure is longer than 8 seconds, the camera will take two exposures with approximately same time for each. Nikon says that the D7000 can sometimes take the second exposure in as little as half the time as the first one. The first exposure is the normal picture-taking exposure. The second one is a black-frame subtraction exposure, which is a second image that is exposed for the about the same duration as the first image, but the shutter is closed. The noise in the black-frame exposure is examined and then subtracted from the original image. It’s really quite effective and beats having to blur the image to get rid of noise. I’ve taken exposures of around 30 seconds and had perfectly usable results. The only drawback is that the total exposure time can be as much as doubled because two exposures are made. The black-frame exposure is not written to the memory card, so you’ll have only one image, with much less noise, in the end. While the black-frame exposure is being processed, a message of Job nr will blink in any active displays. When Job nr is flashing, you cannot use the camera. If you turn it off while Job nr is flashing, the camera will keep the first image, but it won’t do any noise reduction on it.
Anyway, have fun shooting... :)

Pat in NH
 
Last edited:

nickt

Senior Member
Nikon has this to say about Long Exposure Noise reduction: "[the] Noise Reduction feature will take a “dark frame” (a photo with the shutter closed) after the main image, and then electronically “subtract” the noise from the photograph. Because this second photo is taken, the time from pressing the shutter button until the image is recorded is doubled."

Interesting. So, it is a second photo, but not of the scene, just a closed shutter sample. Because I'm pretty sure I have dismounted the camera and come back inside while its still processing to avoid the bugs. This is a good excuse to get off the couch tonight and get re-familiar with night shots. Thanks for the info. And my apologies to Pat.

[/QUOTE]
 

nickt

Senior Member
Nick,I

was incorrect on the mirror staying up but many sources on the net explain there is a 2nd shot, black (not saved). This states the shot is taken with the shutter closed...

This had come up as a question on teh forum a few weeks back which is

Here is one such example....

Nikon knows that their sensors might exhibit more noise than is acceptable in exposures longer than 8 seconds. The sensor can start to warm up a little when longer exposures are used. This causes a condition called amp noise, in which warmer sections of the sensor start to create more noise than cooler sections. There are two settings for Long exp. NR (figure 2):


  • On – When you select On and an exposure is longer than 8 seconds, the camera will take two exposures with approximately same time for each. Nikon says that the D7000 can sometimes take the second exposure in as little as half the time as the first one. The first exposure is the normal picture-taking exposure. The second one is a black-frame subtraction exposure, which is a second image that is exposed for the about the same duration as the first image, but the shutter is closed. The noise in the black-frame exposure is examined and then subtracted from the original image. It’s really quite effective and beats having to blur the image to get rid of noise. I’ve taken exposures of around 30 seconds and had perfectly usable results. The only drawback is that the total exposure time can be as much as doubled because two exposures are made. The black-frame exposure is not written to the memory card, so you’ll have only one image, with much less noise, in the end. While the black-frame exposure is being processed, a message of Job nr will blink in any active displays. When Job nr is flashing, you cannot use the camera. If you turn it off while Job nr is flashing, the camera will keep the first image, but it won’t do any noise reduction on it.

Anyway, have fun shooting... :)

Pat in NH
Thanks Pat! Sorry about the confusion. I learned something here. Happy Father's day!
 

RockyNH_RIP

Senior Member

Interesting. So, it is a second photo, but not of the scene, just a closed shutter sample. Because I'm pretty sure I have dismounted the camera and come back inside while its still processing to avoid the bugs. This is a good excuse to get off the couch tonight and get re-familiar with night shots. Thanks for the info. And my apologies to Pat.

[/QUOTE]


Nick, no apologies my friend, we all make mistakes and I appreciate if someone thinks I am wrong, will point it out... As it was, I misstated the mirror part so I was able to get my t's crossed and i's dotted!! So, Thank You!~

Pat in NH
 
Well many thanks for all the responses Nokonites,

My immediate response to this is that the auto focus function was unable to get a lock on in low light conditions and that was the cause. Are we agreed that the answer to solve this dilemma is to switch the auto focus off as the ambient light subsides and so allow extended shutter speed timing?

I was using the self timer to try and avoid unwanted camera shake.

Incidentally is it possible to use the MUP (mirror up) release mode dial function with the ML-L3 remote wireless trigger?

Many thanks,

Paul.
 

nickt

Senior Member
Yes, the mirror up with remote is in the shooting menu. First press of remote is m-up, 2nd press takes the picture. Top dial stays on remote, not m-up position.
 

nickt

Senior Member
You could manually focus or you might need to find a predetermined focus spot to set your lens when conditions are brighter. Keep in mind infinity may not be 'bottomed out', it may be back a bit from the stop. So focus on infinity during the day so you know where to set your lens when its darker.
 
Yes, the mirror up with remote is in the shooting menu. First press of remote is m-up, 2nd press takes the picture. Top dial stays on remote, not m-up position.

This might be detracting somewhat from my original thread. So it is possible to trigger with a wireless remote with release mode dial set to remote control and benefit from a mirror up shot with consequentially ultra low vibration for pin sharp focus.

Do you agree that it is best to switch off auto focus in low light conditions in order to extend shutter speed?
 

Horoscope Fish

Senior Member
A earlier reply from RockyNH states that in low light conditions the auto focus is unable to focus and so locks out the shutter.
Yes, that's "Shutter Lock". It's a setting on your camera you can turn on or off. You have it set so that your shutter will not fire unless the camera has achieved focus-lock. That's not shutter speed, that's the shutter being locked out entirely until focus-lock is achieved.

​The solution, once again, is to illuminate your subject in order to achieve focus-lock (as I explained earlier), find another, better illuminated subject in order to achieve focus lock, or shoot with manual focus.
 
If I'm taking a long exposure shot, say 20 or 30 seconds, I always see "Job (nr) after the shot has been made, if I wait ten seconds or so the completed image shows up in the display. I believe it takes the camera a few seconds to process the image.
Is this what your're seeing or does an image never appear?

Thanks Ima. This is the first time i have experienced "Job (nr)" on the LCD display. It prevented me from taking further shots and seemed to jam the camera. I think that switching off the auto focus is propably the answer to resolving this.
 

Horoscope Fish

Senior Member
Thanks Ima. This is the first time i have experienced "Job (nr)" on the LCD display. It prevented me from taking further shots and seemed to jam the camera. I think that switching off the auto focus is propably the answer to resolving this.
You need to sit down and spend some time with your manual... This is not an "issue" with anything, you're simply not understanding how your camera works.

You have Long Exposure Noise Reduction enabled on your camera. With this feature enabled your camera automatically takes a second "reference photo" with the shutter closed (pure black). Your camera then uses this reference photo to remove noise from the exposure you took. The "job NR" message is your camera telling you what's it's doing and until it's done processing one picture, it can not take another. This has nothing to do with Auto Focus.
 
You need to sit down and spend some time with your manual... This is not an "issue" with anything, you're simply not understanding how your camera works.

You have Long Exposure Noise Reduction enabled on your camera. With this feature enabled your camera automatically takes a second "reference photo" with the shutter closed (pure black). Your camera then uses this reference photo to remove noise from the exposure you took. The "job NR" message is your camera telling you what's it's doing and until it's done processing one picture, it can not take another. This has nothing to do with Auto Focus.

O.K. in future I will deselect Long Exposure Noise Reduction. It takes too long to process the image even with a 95MB Extreme Pro memory card.

It seems logical that manual focus is preferential to auto focus in low light conditions. I'll report the results of my next sun down expedition.

Mercy.
 
Top