D3100 aftermarket batterygrip for the D5100

Status
Not open for further replies.

900312611

New member
Hello everyone, my name’s Mike and I’m new to this forum, actually so far this is the only camera/photography forum I’m registered on. This maybe a bit long and if it’s against the rules for length I’m very sorry but I have my first question/s to the D5100 users, please. I’ve spent the last 3-4 weeks going back and forth between Canon and Nikon, first with the T2i/T3i & the D3100 & D5100…then the D90 & 60D, and then ventured into the D7000; 700 and 300s then to the Canon higher ups; I have the money (retired and tax refund). Brief photography history; back about 30 years ago I had a Nikon FE, I know-entry level and not a F3 but it was manual and I got pretty good at it till the wife nagged about the cost etc. so it was put aside. 20 years later I sold it after it sat in the closet forever so long and got a cheap Nikon N4004 (didn’t know it was cheap model back then, it was $500 some 15 years or so ago) for the wife, this has been used occasionally but never extently (word?) till now the digital world…I never got a P&S but now have all sorts of time and discretionary money [not rich]. So far I can think my main interest is only in photos; maybe video later (because it’s on most newer cameras but right now only photos), no interest in sports videos per say maybe wildlife later but mostly landscape, buildings, and trees (landscape)… some of the trees here have the strangest shapes and would look great in B/W, not an Ansell Adams and don’t have the money for med. format but thought his photos were fantastic. So this is why, right now, I’m looking at the D5100/T2i or T3i. D5100 is supposed to have the D7000 sensor and the Rebels somewhat the 7D sensors. I keep coming back to the D5100 but it, and the T2(3)I are small; yes I know a lot of people like the smallness but I find it just doesn’t feel like anything till you get up to a 90D… so my question(s) are…took a long time to get to this point: THERE IS NO battery grip for the D5100. I’ve tried all sorts of wording on search engines and have only found 2 places where the aftermarket D3100 grip was put on the D5100 but only after filing/grinding down the GPS door side of the grip a little, but no one said if these, Meike, Keiko, and other Chinese grips worked 100% on their D5100, supposedly, I gather, there are no problems on the D3100, at least I haven’t read any, but since pretty much every forum/ review I’ve seen points to the D5100 over the D3100 as better image quality and edges out the Canon T2i&T3i in the same area, but the Rebels do have dedicated battery grips for them (contact points) I am wanting the D5100, and get good glass for it (decided that the D90. D7000, 700, 300s would too much of a learning curve right now, maybe latter but I figure you can get really good pictures with the D5100 and if need be edit them later…probably no need to spend an extra $400 -$1000 on something that is supposed to take as good images as the D7000… so surly some of you, or many of you, out there with a D5100 have wanted a battery grip either for the 2 batteries (thought I’ve heard the batteries are in parallel) or for the shear handling part (vertical shots and just to make it feel better in your hands) have put on the aftermarket D3100 battery grip on their D5100 or at least have known someone that did. Did everything function on the camera, did something not work that should’ve, did it breakdown shortly after, anything you can tell me about your experience because this is the deciding factor for Nikon at this stage, if it doesn’t really work right I guess I’ll go over to the T3i. Second question: are all of you happy with the Image quality? Any complaints, any I wish I would’ve gotten this instead of that? How high iso did you go and what glass do you use. Can you D5100 users help me out please?
 
Last edited:

PavementPilot

New member
Well, one thing to consider if you use the D3100 grip is, there is no battery selector switch. Over on Flickr, in the D3100 group we have been having quite the discussion about this. I have noticed erratic battery levels when both batteries are mounted. I have since resorted to only loading one battery at a time. I will still continue to use the grip, as it adds what I need for my hand size. I also like the portrait shutter button, even though it needs the cable to communicate that function.

I have been contemplating modifying my grip by putting a battery selector switch on the outside, but I am not into doing electronic soldering, or curcuit building. I do know how to read a schematic.
 

900312611

New member
I think I saw yours on flicker, if I'm right you did pretty much an extensive test with the batteries, other than the battery issue, and the cable going into the gps door slot everything on your D5100 workrd properly, no on/off problems, menue problems, or shutter release trouble? Am I correct that you had to grind/file one side to get it to sit properly? Thanks for the reply. I saw on one site, think meike, who knows, but they had a D3100 grip with a lcd readout.
 
A little off subject BUT. I recently got the D3100 and have been quite surprised by the quality. I used to shoot a Mamiya 645 medium format many years ago BD (before digital) I sent off a shot from my D3100 to a well know lab to have a 12 X 18 done. When it came back it look as good or better than anything I ever shot with the Mamiya 645. I am going to push the limits and get a 20 X 24 printed once I get "The shot" I like. Buy a D3100 or D5100 and save the money for good glass.
 

900312611

New member
I know this isn't exactly what you wanted, but I don't know how to copy/post the actual link,I just put in lcd battery grip and all sorts will come...while hunting for you I found that the LCD on the grips is just a stopwatch type timer.


Anyone out there with a D5100 and put on a battery grip on it?
 

900312611

New member
I found your other posts and flicker, I'm guesing you have a D3100, anyway with your battery grip do you still have the '1/2 press-shutter release' for Auto Focus function?
 

900312611

New member
Gee, 81 views already, still early, and no one, but tracoft and paymentpilot, have responded, and as nice as they were to respond still the question at hand goes without answer. It's hard to believe that as many D5100 users as are out there and are members of this forum, and this is a D5100 forum, that no one or anyone that knows of one that has wanted, or bought and used one of these aftermarket grips on their d5100 can come forward with any help on the subject.:confused:
 

PavementPilot

New member
Its nothing to really get upset about. I have asked questions before, and they have gone unanswered. It is just the right people havent seen it. I have one question that hasnt even gotten a single reply.
 

900312611

New member
This is for the reply from fotojack:
Well gosh golly gee that was real witty now wasn't it, but that wasn't the question now was it. I'm sure you could see...hopefully... that I pretty much acknowledged in so many words that there was no grip for the D5100, but went on to say that I had found that some people had put one for the D3100 on the D5100 but didn't go into detail and say one way or the other if everything functioned...thinking this being a Nikon user forum, and with a dedicated D5100 group, maybe just maybe some of the thousands of people that click on this site either have done the same, wondered the same, wanted the same, or know of someone who has tried it. It be nice to know that you are not representive of the majority of respondants here, one would only hope. I really would like to end this with alpha hotel but I won't, I like to think I'm above that.
 
Last edited:

fotojack

Senior Member
hmmm.......maybe I should have started reading your problem from post #1, but I didn't. Somehow I ended up reading about it on post #9. So I started hunting around the net for a grip for your D5100. Couldn't find anything anywhere, even on one of my favourite sites for camera equipment.......Linkdelight.com: Great buys on Photography Equipment, Outdoor Equipment, Toys and More . So I answered as truthfully as I saw fit. You took this as being witty?? OK.....whatever. Hope you find what you're looking for.
 

bluenoser

Banned
Gee, 81 views already, still early, and no one, but tracoft and paymentpilot, have responded, and as nice as they were to respond still the question at hand goes without answer.

It's nothing personal - would you have preferred 80 people to respond by saying "read your post but can't help you"? (do you respond to every single thread that you read??)

That's life on any forum - happens all the time - not just to poor little Mikey.

It's hard to believe that as many D5100 users as are out there and are members of this forum, and this is a D5100 forum, that no one or anyone that knows of one that has wanted, or bought and used one of these aftermarket grips on their d5100 can come forward with any help on the subject.:confused:

Actually it's not hard to believe at all if you had done your homework on this site (which you clearly didn't) If you had, you'd have noticed that there is a dearth of threads about the D5100 and none indicating that anyone here actually owns one!

Please keep in mind that this camera was only announced by Nikon last month (!) and it didn't hit the retail stores until sometime after that. In other words - not many people have had the chance to purchase it yet so you shouldn't expect a large body of knowledge to exist about the camera - and certainly not about a battery grip that Nikon doesn't even list on it's site as an option!

Why are you chastising the people on this forum? No one here or anywhere else owes you a reply. Are you not capable of understanding that the lack or response to your thread just *might* be due to the fact that no one has the answer to your question? Is it that unfathomable? (or must everything be a personal shot at you?)

Your activity in this thread has been nothing short of childish and narcissistic. Enough with the spoiled - only child routine please.

Perhaps it's because there aren't any for the D5100? I don't know............just guessing.

This is for the reply from fotojack:
Well gosh golly gee that was real witty now wasn't it, but that wasn't the question now was it. I'm sure you could see...hopefully... that I pretty much acknowledged in so many words that there was no grip for the D5100, but went on to say that I had found that some people had put one for the D3100 on the D5100 but didn't go into detail and say one way or the other if everything functioned...thinking this being a Nikon user forum, and with a dedicated D5100 group, maybe just maybe some of the thousands of people that click on this site either have done the same, wondered the same, wanted the same, or know of someone who has tried it. It be nice to know that you are not representive of the majority of respondants here, one would only hope. I really would like to end this with alpha hotel but I won't, I like to think I'm above that.
Jack gave you a completely reasonable answer but once again you take it the wrong way and respond with sarcasm and bile.

The fact is Jack is most likely correct for the reasons I stated above. Boo-hoo.

Yet you still expect replies to a highly unique and improbable set of circumstances: a brand new camera (D5100) for which no dedicated battery grip from Nikon is available for (or to date from any other 3rd party manufacturer) and you want to know who has this brand new camera because you assume of course that all of these people have scoured the internet looking for a battery grip that doesn't yet exist! However, not to be deterred - all of these people decided to buy a D3100 3rd party grip and file down the end to make it "fit" on a camera it wasn't designed to be used with!!!!! Gee...I just can't imagine why you're not getting an avalanche of replies to your question - the mind boggles!

Your assumptions in this post reinforce your poor attitude and general lack of understanding about this site and the new product cycle of a camera .

You've been a real charmer so far. I hope you regroup and start again with a better attitude. The people here are very friendly and helpful - but things may not roll-out within a time frame that is catered to you! (horror of horrors).

If you need a camera that has a battery grip option then get the D7000, etc. If you love the D5100 stop belly aching and get it - surely a battery grip won't be a make or break deal for you will it?
 
Last edited:

900312611

New member
Homework? um...Nikon forum, D5100=Nikon, D5100 group on this forum. Internet= millions of people, "Yet you still expect replies to a highly unique and improbable set of circumstances" what would be the unique and improbable set of circumstances? "and certainly not about a battery grip that Nikon doesn't even list on it's site as an option" Nikon doesn't make one for D3100 either (but that was acknowledged) , but that didn't stop poeple from getting an aftermarket. "respond with sarcasm and bile" point out the bile other that yours, thought fotojack"s response was pretty much unwarranted sarcasm. Your assumptions in this post" what assumption, that this has the possibility to be seen be thousands... maybe someone may know of someone? " The people here are very friendly and helpful , like you who has been a member a few weeks? Why are you chastising the people on this forum], who did I chastise? " narcissistic? maybe you should look at yourself,... self apointed (new) leader of the forum? "and you want to know who has this brand new camera because you assume of course that all of these people have scoured the internet looking for a battery grip that doesn't yet exist! However, not to be deterred - all of these people decided to buy a D3100 3rd party grip and file down the end to make it "fit" on a camera it wasn't designed to be used with"... don't believe I assumed anything was just aksing in a fourm that is seen by many. Don't understand the rest of your statement; also D3100 not designed for one either or Nikon would have made one, but that didn't stop some chinese from making one. Anyway do you now feel like a real man for getting that all out? PS: D5100 came on the market Mar. 11, 2011, not last month.
 
Last edited:

bluenoser

Banned
Homework? um...Nikon forum, D5100=Nikon, D5100 group on this forum. Internet= millions of people, "Yet you still expect replies to a highly unique and improbable set of circumstances" what would be the unique and improbable set of circumstances? "and certainly not about a battery grip that Nikon doesn't even list on it's site as an option" Nikon doesn't make one for D3100 either (but that was acknowledged) , but that didn't stop poeple from getting an aftermarket. "respond with sarcasm and bile" point out the bile other that yours, thought fotojack"s response was pretty much unwarranted sarcasm. Your assumptions in this post" what assumption, that this has the possibility to be seen be thousands... maybe someone may know of someone? " The people here are very friendly and helpful , like you who has been a member a few weeks? Why are you chastising the people on this forum], who did I chastise? " narcissistic? maybe you should look at yourself,... self apointed (new) leader of the forum? "and you want to know who has this brand new camera because you assume of course that all of these people have scoured the internet looking for a battery grip that doesn't yet exist! However, not to be deterred - all of these people decided to buy a D3100 3rd party grip and file down the end to make it "fit" on a camera it wasn't designed to be used with"... don't believe I assumed anything was just aksing in a fourm that is seen by many. Don't understand the rest of your statement; also D3100 not designed for one either or Nikon would have made one, but that didn't stop some chinese from making one. Anyway do you now feel like a real man for getting that all out?

A very "nicely" (i.e. brutally) formatted reply Mikey. New to the internet are we?

Thank you for once again proving my point in spades Mikey. You're making this too easy.

PS: D5100 came on the market Mar. 11, 2011, not last month.
Wrong again Mikey...It was officially announced on April 5, 2011: see the Nikon press release HERE (facts are a tough one to get around aren't they?) I'm betting Mar 11 is probably your birthday - likely why your getting the dates confused. Life can be confusing like that sometimes.

Like I said - you're making it just too easy. A guy like you is gold to someone like me.

I hope you find your D5100 battery grip - you know the one that doesn't exist yet. However if you contact Nikon directly and tell them it's for "Mikey", they'll make one up special just for you (and probably name it after you I would think).

You're aces with me Mikey. :rolleyes:

Mods: Don't worry, I'm done with this guy and won't be reply to his next inane reply. Mikey likes to have the last word (so I'll let him) :)
 
Last edited:

900312611

New member
I'm sure your fellow forum users are real proud of how you represent them as you do, just goes to show the kind of people(?) they let loose on these forums. Wallow in your self rightousness, you only show how small you are.
You wanted me to have the last word, so I don't want to disappoint you.
Excell in your life
 

jdeg

^ broke something
Staff member
Okay guys - no reason to get all cranky. Remember, voice inflection isn't possible on a forum. Take things with a grain of salt.

Mike - sorry your first post didn't meet your expectations.

The question was effectively answered.

Closed
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top