Will I regret...
- Thread starter richnmib
- Start date
BackdoorArts
Senior Member
The only potential regret may be not getting the Sport version. That version is seriously heavy, but seriously great optically. The bokeh I get on my bird shots is soooo good compared to what I used to get from the 150-500mm. And I'm not talking distant stuff, I'm talking from scattered branches within the same tree. I managed to grab it at an amazing sale price at B&H a while back ($200 off, and the USB dock and a $250 UV filter were thrown in), so it was a no brainer (I'd been waiting for a year to buy it).
Whether or not it's worth $1000 more depends on how much and how you'll use it. But my love for the Sport does not discount how good the Contemporary is. For the hobbiest it's wonderful.
Whether or not it's worth $1000 more depends on how much and how you'll use it. But my love for the Sport does not discount how good the Contemporary is. For the hobbiest it's wonderful.
Chris@sabor
Senior Member
No regrets here! Probably the best investment I've made so far...
I have never regretted the Nikon 200-500mm lens purchase. Yes, it's a 100mm shorter and more expensive than the Siggy C , but the IQ and the bokeh, soooooo good! (the images posted on this forum doesn't do it justice) Plus it's an f/5.6. (there are plenty shots on Flickr by now taken with a TC attached)
Having said that, you should go with your gut feeling. I'm sure you've done enough research by now. Good luck.
Having said that, you should go with your gut feeling. I'm sure you've done enough research by now. Good luck.
I've used my sons 150-600C a few times now. And all I can say is it takes very nice, sharp pictures. The sucker is heavy. If/when I get one of these beasts. It will be the sports model even though they are slightly larger and heavier I've yet to hear anything bad about them.
I feel exactly the same way about the 200-500mm. If I'd bought the Siggy C I doubt I'd have regretted it but I think I'd always be wondering if I should have bought the Sport or Nikkor instead.
As for the images on the forum not doing the lens justice, I'm not sure if that is a compliment to the lens, an insult to those of us who shoot it or an acknowledgment that posting on a forum isn't going to show the photos at their best? I'm thinking/hoping it is more the former and latter, I know my shots show much more detail in lightroom before I post them here and that the lens is capable of producing far better results than I can, so in that sense it isn't being done justice. But i've seen a lot of good work with it on here from everyone using it.
BackdoorArts
Senior Member
I've shot with a lot of long telephoto lenses. With every other one I would have had to clone out the branch in the OOF area, and the bokeh would have been a mish-mosh of light and dark areas from the trees that are about 4-5 feet behind the bird. The Sport is just better. There's a price to be paid in weight and wallet, but I marvel at what I don't have to deal with in post any more.
Danno
Senior Member
Last edited:
That is what I meant by it. No way I would ever insult any of my fellow Nikonites. (unless in self defense)
So what are you trying to say Pete... hmmmm....
I'm saying that it's night and day between posting images here and reality when it comes to judging IQ on a piece of glass. When it comes to bokeh that's different. Bad bokeh is bad bad bokeh, and I can't stand it.
Danno
Senior Member
I'm saying that it's night and day between posting images here and reality when it comes to judging IQ on a piece of glass. When it comes to bokeh that's different. Bad bokeh is bad bad bokeh, and I can't stand it.
Actually I agree... and I THOUGHT i knew what you meant
... I love the 200-500 and when I do my job right I am so happy with the results. But I had to give you just a little bit of a hard time That is what I meant by it. No way I would ever insult any of my fellow Nikonites. (unless in self defense)
I thought as much but wasn't sure, that's the trouble with written text, tone and meaning are easily lost. Sorry I doubted you
Thank you all for your replies. I ordered the Sigma C. The sport was just too much. It will be here friday. I am sure there will be a learning curve with this lens but I am looking forward to learning it. I know a spot that has burrowing owls and then there is always the Circle B.
Danno
Senior Member
Congrats on your purchase. It is so nice that these new lenses are in reach, and all of them produce such excellent results. Look forward to seeing your first shots.
Looking forward to some Circle B shots with that lens.:encouragement: