I can't decide which of these two lenses makes the most sense. The D is a smaller profile lens but the G will give more spherical bokeh relative to the D lens but is there anything more significant that this? The reviews I've read so far would lead me to believe the D is a little faster on the focus and possibly sharper but I can't seem to find anyone willing to say this directly, which makes me think perhaps I'm reading too much between the lines. So I'm hoping someone here has experience with both lenses.
Thanks!

I would pass on both of them and get the new 50 1.8G:

"The Nikon 50mm f/1.8G sets new standards in 50mm fixed lens performance for Nikon mount – it is sharper than all of the predecessors, including the Nikon 50mm f/1.4G at largest apertures."

Nikon 50mm f/1.8G Review

Originally Posted by bluenoser

I would pass on both of them and get the new 50 1.8G:


Nikon 50mm f/1.8G Review

Very interesting. I read this review a few weeks back and forgot that he also compared it to the 1.4D. Thanks

Now the tough part is finding a lens. Eveyone is out of stock...go figure!

Originally Posted by DWPhotos

Now the tough part is finding a lens. Eveyone is out of stock...go figure!

It's a popular lens for a reason! Hang in there - one will turn up soon.

Success! Nelson Photo here in San Diego has one! I knew there was a reason I liked this store. On my way right now...

Originally Posted by DWPhotos

Success! Nelson Photo here in San Diego has one! I knew there was a reason I liked this store. On my way right now...

Congrats! (ask Nelson Photo for my commission...)